The Report of The Outbreak Of Pneumonia
By Legionella At
Alcala De Henares
Madrid, April of 1997
INDEX:
I PRESENTATION
II INTRODUCTION
111 METHODOLOGICAL ASPECTS
III.1-Definition of cases
III.2-Encuesta case and analysis diagnostics
III.3-Tecnicas epidemiologist of laboratory
IV. DESCRIPTIVE STUDY OF THE OUTBREAK
IV. 1.-Number of cases -
IV. 2.-Manifestaciones clinical -
IV. 3.-Evolucio'n of the -
IV. 4.-Caracteristicas cases of temporo space -
IV. 5.-Distribution person -
V. - MICROBIOLOGICAL RESULTS
VI. - ENVIRONMENTAL INVESTIGATION
VII. - ANALYSIS EPIDEMIOLOGIST
VIII MEASURES OF CONTROL
IX. - CONCLUSIONS X BIBLIOGRAPHY
XI. - ANNEXED: Preventive Actions Forehead To New Outbreaks
of Legionella
PRESENTATION
The handling and management of an epidemic outbreak of legionellosis, like which it took place in the months of September and October of 1996 in Alcala de Henares, are always complex, and require to establish a solid and complex strategy of coordination between professionals, non sanitary toilets and, specialized in different disciplines from the scientific knowledge (clinical, microbiologists, epidemiologists, industrial professionals of Environmental Salud, engineers and others). But in addition, tratandose of a outbreak of legionellosis opened in the community, with the consequent difficulties of location and control of the center origin of the same one, that affected an elevated number of people, with the social impact that it entails, does that the effort to develop by the health institutions is still more considerable. In the management of this epidemic outbreak, that fundamentally affected a zone of Alcala de Henares of 46,000 inhabitants, the administrations were implied Local, Autonomic and Central:
The City council of Alcala de Henares, person in charge of whatever affects to the health between its citizens.
Social Consejeria of Health and Services of the Community of Madrid as Sanitary Administration Regional person in charge of the investigation of the outbreak and to dictate and to control the application of the preventive measures of Public Salud for its eradication.
The Hospital Prince of Asturias of INSALUD, pertaining to the Ministry of
Health and Consumo, person in charge of the sanitary attention of the patients.
Institute de Salad Carlos III, also pertaining to the Ministry of Health and
Consumo, through its National Centro of Microbiology, like Central Laboratory of
support to National Sistema of Salud.
With the purpose of reinforcing the mechanisms of institutional coordination
and unifying the messages directed to the inhabitants of Alcala de Henares and
to means of communication, in Consejeria de Social Health and Services a
Committee of Experts constituted itself, with representatives of the three
implied administrations and of Scientific Societies, that made valuable
contributions in the management of the outbreak. The composition of this
Committee was the following one:
- President of the Committee:
*Dna. Rosa Posada Chapado (Advisor of Health and Social Servicios)
- Institutional Representation: -
*D. Bartholomew Gonzalez Jime'nez (Mayor of Alcala de Henares)
*D. Jesus Fermosell Diaz (Social Viceconsejero of Health and Servicios)
*D. Left Navarrese Albino (Provincial Director of Madrid of INSALUD)
*D. Jose Luis Perez de Rueda (Advisor of General Director of Instituto de Salud Carlos III)
Technical Representation:
Council of Health and Social Services:
*D. Jose JovereIbarra (Head of Serviciode Public Salud of Area IV)
*D. Rafael Bueno Fenceable (Head of Service de Epidemiology's)
*D. Luis Vela'zquez Goodable (Head of Service de Public Salud of Area III)
*D. Emilio Bable Santiago (Head of Service of Microbiology of the Hospital Gregorio Mara6no'n) -
Hospital Prince of Asturias of INSALUD:
*D. Robert Col Yurrita (Managing director)
*D. Angel Sanz Aiz (Medical Director)
*D. Joaquin Lopez Alvarez (Head of Service de Internal Medicine)
*Dna. Maria Beltran Dubon (Head of Service de Microbiology) -
Institute of Salud Carlos III:
*Dna. Odorina Table Wideable (Director of National Center of Epidemiology)
*D. Carlos Jorge Domingo Fernandez (Director of National Center of Microbiology)
*D. Alvaro the Olive Lozanos (Head of Service de Microbiology Diagnostic of National Centro of Epidemiology)
*D. Jose Manuel Echevarria May (Head of Service of Orientacion Diagnostic of National Centro of Microbiology
Dna. Carmen Pelaz Antolin (Responsible for the Laboratory of Legionella of National Center of Microbiology)
D. Fernando de Ory Mancho'n (Head of Section of Microbiology Diagnostic of National Centro of Microbiologoy)
*Dna. Cecilia Seaable Seine fishingable (Head of Area of Investigation of National Center of Microbiology)
Coordinating of the Committee:
*D. Felipe Vable Herranz (General Director of Prevention and Promotion of Salud of Consejeria de Sanidad and Social Services)
The present report must as objective present/display investigations made during the outbreak, directed to know its origin and eliminate able, and the results of the same ones, like final basic document, support of possible scientific developments that in the future can take place in their different slopes, epidemiologist, microbiological clinic and. In him all the sanitary professionals responsible for such investigations have participated, and constitutes in addition the report that on the outbreak they emit, to common agreement, the implied administrations.
INTRODUCTION
Day 11 of September of 1996 the sanitary services of the INSALUD of Alcala de Henares notified Servicio de Public Salud of Area 3, of Consejeria of Social Hanidad and Services, an increase on the habitual thing of the extra hospital numbers of pneumonia taken care of in the Hospital Prince of Asturias in the two previous weeks. One was pneumonia that responded favourably to the treatment with eritromicina and not with other guidelines of antibiotic treatment. Immediately, from Service of Public Health of Area 3, an equipment of epidemiologists initiated the investigation epidemiologist, in narrow collaboration with the sanitary professionals of the Hospital Prince of Asturias and Primary Atencion of the municipality, with the purpose of confirming the existence of an epidemic outbreak and sustaining a work hypothesis that as far as possible allowed the adoption of measures of control of that one.
At the same time, the opportune devices of monitoring articulated epidemiologist at local and regional level. Thanks to the computerized registry of Service of admission de emergencies of the Hospital, could be confirmed, comparing the present cases with the taken care of ones and entering of previous years, the existence of a outbreak of pneumonia and a space grouping of cases in the North zone of Alcala de Henares. Cases identified retrospectively of pneumonia taken care of and entere in Hospital from 25 of August (date in which the manifest beginning of the outbreak was demonstrated) and a survey was designed and applied to these cases oriented epidemiologist to describe the outbreak and to identify the common to cases and associated factors of risk to pictures of pneumonica pulmonary affectation. The results of this survey revealed the following excellent findings: aggregation of cases in the average labour relative did not exist nor; common exhibition to closed places of public concurrence did not exist; there were no common antecedents of exhibition to animals; they did not exist antecedent of food ingestion of suspicious origin (sanitarily not controlled) or unusual in the habitual diet of the cases; indications of implication of some toxic agent did not exist either; the average age of the affected ones was of 68 years. The previous findings, next to the clinical evidences and the good answer to the antibiotic treatment with eritromicina, oriented the etiological hypothesis towards an infectious outbreak of pneumonia in the community, probably due to Legionella. At that same moment the environmental investigation began, directed to locate emitting centers of aerosols contaminated by Legionella. Immediately after known the first results microbiological that guaranteed the legionellosis hypothesis, the appropriate preventive measures for the population of Alcala de Henares were started. Later, the etiologic hypothesis of a outbreak of pneumonia by Legionella definitively was confirmed by new microbiological results. The cases studied in this report correspond to all those that, fulfilling the case definitions which sanitary Prince of Asturias and other centers between the 25 of August settle down themselves, were taken care of in the Hospital and the 26 of October of 1996 (date of sanitary attention of the last case including in the outbreak). After these dates the opportune devices of monitoring stayed in alert (and they are continued maintaining at the present time) epidemiologist, without new cases related to the outbreak were detected.
METHODOLOGICAL ASPECTS
Definition of case
With the purpose of defining the cases to include in the outbreak a
classification of the same ones in three categories has settled down:
suspicious, probable and confirmed cases. This classification has been made
taking care of a clinical criterion and microbiological criteria and
epidemiologists. Clinical criterion: It is constituted by those clinical
premises including in Provisional Operative Definition of case handled by the
Hospital Prince of Asturias during the pursuit of the outbreak, once established
highly probable the etiological hypothesis of legionellosis. This criterion
includes:
Greater criteria:
1. Time of evolution of the symptoms inferior to 10 days.
2. - Radiological infiltrated presence of pulmonary.
Smaller criteria:
(a)- Fever.
(b) - general Malaise, artromialgias or migraine.
(c) - respiratory Symptoms: cough, giveable or pleuritico pain.
(d) - alveolo-arterial Gradient superior to 20 mmable.
Criteria of exclusion: · Positive Baciloscopia in respiratory secretions. · * Bacterial isolation in blood, pleural liquid or secretion bronchial, different from Legionella. · * High suspicion of broncoaspiracion. · *Diagnosis of another specific disease that could justify the symptoms. For the fulfilment of the clinical criterion the fulfilment of the greater criteria is required, of three of smaller the criteria and the absence of all the criteria of exclusion.
Microbiological criteria: wo types of microbiological criteria settle
down: Criteria of confirmation:
1.-Aislamiento de Legionella in biological samples.
2. - Demonstration of a quadruple or greater increase of the title of
antibodies as opposed to Legionella pneumophila SG1, until reaching 1/128 more
or.
3. - Demonstration of a title of antibodies as opposed to Legionella
pneumophila SG1 ³1/256
Suggestive criteria:
a) - Detection of antigen of Legionella pneumophila SG1 in orable by
enzimoinmunoensayo.
b) - Detection of Legionella pneumophila SG1 in biological samples by means
of enzymatic amplification of DNA (PCR).
c) - Demonstration of a quadruple or greater increase of the title of
antibodies as opposed to Legionella pneumophila SG1, up to 1/64. d) -
Demonstration of a maintained title of antibodies as opposed to Legionella
pneumophila SG1 of 1/128.
Criteria epidemiologists: Initially, Provisional Operative Definition of
Cases included the criterion in the last residence epidemiologist month in
Alcala de Henares. With it was tried that the definition was highly sensible.
Later, as the high percentage of cases with microbiological criteria of
confirmation was observed that lived or been recently had exposed to the North
zone of Alcala (97.63%), was decided, with the purpose of increasing to the
specificity of the definition, maintaining the high sensitivity, making the
criterion more restrictive epidemiologist of exhibition and to reclasifition the
cases according to the same one. On the basis of the previous thing, the
following criteria settled down epidemiologists who now we maintain:
1. - To reside habitually in the North zone of Alcala that
includes/understands municipal districts 7, 8 and sections censusable 4, 5, 7,
8, 14 and 15 of district 6.
2. To have visited at some moment, during the three previous weeks in the
beginning of the disease, the North zone of described Alcala.
3. According to these criteria they are distinguished:
CASES SUSPICIOUS:
All case that, having received medical assistance between days 25 of August and 26 of October of 1996, the criterion fulfils clinical and one of the epidemiologists.
CASES PROBABLE:
All suspicious case that it fulfils one or more of the suggestive
microbiological criteria.
CASES CONFIRMED:
All suspicious or probable case that it fulfils one or more of the
microbiological criteria of confirmation.
Survey and I design epidemiologist
After the notification to Service of Public Salud of Area III of
Consejeria of Health and Social Services, on the part of the services of medical
assistance of the INSALUD of Alcala de Henares, of the cases that motivated the
suspicion of the outbreak, information of the computerized registry of Service
of Admission of Emergencies of the Hospital was successfully obtained Prince of
Asturias, that included name and last names of the taken care of cases, date of
attention toilet, date of birth, I domicile, telephone, initial diagnosis and
destiny of the patient.
In agreement with this information, that it allowed to identify initially to
the possible cases taken care of by the hospital, it was designed and it made
one first survey oriented epidemiologist to describe the outbreak and to
identify the common to cases and associated factors of risk to pictures of
pneumonic pulmonary affectation: animal trips, exhibition, exhibition to places
public, ingestion of unusual foods or origin non controlled sanitarily and
exhibition to other well-known cases.
Later, once known the first positive results serological Legionella, that
guaranteed the initial hypothesis of a legionellosis outbreak, one second
oriented survey was designed fundamentally to investigate the exhibition of the
cases to possible sources of formation of aerosols, as much in the home as in
the public route: use of the shower in the home, centralized sanitary hot water,
routine strolls, exhibition to places closed public, etc. Also the intense
aggregation of cases in the same one was asked specifically for the exhibition
the zone of Alcala de Henares considered like zone of risk, given North: zone
inhabited to the north of Complutensian Vi'a that includes/understands municipal
districts 7, 8 and sections censusable 6-4, 6-5, 6-7, 6-8, 6-14 and 6-15, all of
them of district 6.
This second survey was made to all the possible cases that were appearing
during the outbreak, either by telephone, or personally when the patients
remained entered, not knowing the encuestadores the classification of each
patient at the moment for making the survey, when not having then the
microbiological information of those. With the information gathered in this
survey the study of the environmental factors of risk was carried out, valuing
the exhibition to the same ones in a period of three weeks before the beginning
of the symptoms.
The studied factors of risk were: exhibition to the zone of risk, exhibition
to the contaminated cooling towers with the same stock of Legionella detected in
the patients, exhibition to the shower in the home, existence in sanitary hot
the water house centralized and existence in the building of the house of
potable water tank. In order to study the exhibition to the cooling towers an
influence area was defined for each one of them, locating the tower in the
center of a circle of 200 meters of radio, in agreement with the established
thing in similar studies, and recodifition the database valuing itself for each
patient the exhibition to this area, considering the address of the patients and
the routes followed in the made strolls the three previous weeks in the
beginning of the disease (routine or precise strolls to go to concrete places or
by reason for leisure). The analysis of the environmental factors of risk was
made by means of two complementary designs:
1. - I design
1: A study of cases and controls with the following definitions has been
made:
*Cases: All patient taken care of in a sanitary center from the 25 of
August the 26 of October of 1996, resident one in Alcala de Henares or that has
visited the city during the three previous weeks in the beginning of its
disease, with clinical diagnosis of pneumonia and microbiological criterion of
confirmation of recent infection by Legionella.
*Control All patient taken care of in a health center from the 25th of August
the 26th of October of 1996, resident one in Alcala de Henares or that he has
visited the city during the three previous weeks in the beginning of its
disease, with clinical diagnosis pneumonia (excluded those from well-known cause
different from Legionella) and without microbiological criterion of confirmation
of recent infection by Legionella.
2. - I design
2: A study of cases and controls with the following
definitions has been made: *Case: All patient who was entered in the Hospital
Prince of Asturias the 8 of October of 1996, resident in Alcala de Henares, with
clinical diagnosis of pneumonia according to Provisional Operative Definition of
case (possible case of legionellosis), excluding the cases with stays superior
to 15 days before the 8 from October. *Control: All patient entered the Hospital
Prince of Asturias 15 days before or after the 8 of October, by cause different
from pneumonia, excluding all respiratory pathology or febrile process 30 days
before the entrance, and resident in Alcala de Henares. controls have mated by
sex and age (±5 years).
2 controls by case have been chosen. In the analysis of both designs Ratios
with intervals of different species and serogroups from Legionella, and those
isolated ones identified like L. pneumophila SG1 were sub-group able with the
standardized panel of monoclonales antibodies, who allows his classification in
three greater sub-groups, Pontiac, Olda and Bellingham, and ten smaller
sub-groups.
3.-Detection of Legionella by means of direct inmunofluorescencia in samples
of beable, respiratory secretions obtained by broncoscopia and pulmonary weave,
using commercial preparing and following indications of the manufacturer.
4. - Detection of antigen of L. pneumophila SG1 in orable by means of
enzimo-inmunoensayo, using commercial preparing and putting under some of the
samples to a technique of selective ultrafiltration.
5.-Detection of genomic material of Legionella pneumophila by means of
enzymatic amplification of DNA (PCR), using the " Enviro Amp " Legionella kit.
In addition to the diagnosticas tests for legionellosis, to all the cases of
protocolizada form the following studies were also made to them:
Serologroup A)-Estudio of antibodies as opposed to influenza To, influenza B,
adenovirus, sincitial respiratory virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, Coxiella
burnetti phase II and Chlamydia psittaci, by fixation of the complement,
according to a standard procedure.
b)-Hemocultivo for different pathogens, excluyen dose the cases with positive
hemocultivo different from Legionella.
C)-Estudio of isolation in different types from cellular cultures for the
detection of viral agents
D)-Estudio of electronic microscopy for search of different Pathogens. For the culture of Legionella from the samples of environmental origin, these were seeded, after their concentration and decontaminacio'n 4,5, in means of culture BABLE and MWY. The subgrupado identification and of the isolated ones was made as it has been detailed previously for the clinical samples.
DESCRIPTIVE STUDY OF THE OUTBREAK Nº of cases
Table 1 presents/displays the cases including in the outbreak, in agreement
with the criteria of established, distributed inclusion of case according to its
classification in certainty degrees and confidence to 95% like measurement of
the effect calculated Odds. In design 2 the calculations for matched up data
have been made. The estimations were made by stratified analysis and logistic
regression in design 1 and by bivariant analysis in design 2. For all the
calculations of rates of population incidence the data of Municipal Padro'n of
Alcala de Henares updated to November of 1996 have been used. Diagnosticas
techniques of laboratory The used techniques of laboratory for the legionellosis
diagnosis were the following ones:
1.-Deteccio'n of antibodies as opposed to Legionella pneumophila SG1 by IFI,
according to technique used by the microbiology laboratory.
2.-Aislamiento and identification of the bacterium by means of culture of
samples of respiratory secretions (esputos and samples obtained by broncoscopia),
woven of autopsy and pulmonary biopsies. The culture of the bacterium was
carried out by means of direct inoculation in means of culture BABLE and BMPA in
the case of samples noncontaminated and in BABLE, after a process of
decontamination, in thre case of the esputos. The identification of the isolated
ones was made as opposed to by means of IFI sanitary centers in which they were
attended, being these those that notified and informed the cases.
Although from Primary Attention more cases were notified, in the single
corresponding column have been reflected the cases taken care of exclusively in
that attendable level, incluyen dose in the one of the Hospital Prince of
Asturias the cases derived to the same one for their attendance. If we excluded
from the total of cases 3 that they did not have habitual residence in Alcala de
Henares, a rate is from incidence for all the population of this municipality of
132 cases by 100,000 inhabitants.
The existing discrepancy between the total number of cases taken care of by the Hospital Prince of Asturias that when finalizing the outbreak occurred like official (262 cases) and the present number (214 cases), must to that that one, being provisional, has been corrected when applying the definitive criteria of inclusion of case, descartadose 48 patients that when not fulfilling such criteria cannot be considered as cases of the outbreak
Table 1. - Distribution of cases according to its classification and
centers of medical assistance.
Classification |
Hospital Prince |
Primary Attention of Alcala de Henares |
Other Hospitals | Total |
| Confirmed | 86 | 4 | 2 | 92 |
| Probable | 42 | 42 | ||
| suspects | 86 | 4 | 90 | |
| Total | 214 | 8 | 2 | 224 |
Clinical manifestations
In this section the excellent clinical data of all the cases taken care of in the Hospital appear Prince of Asturias.
The clinical sintomatologi'a of the cases was the following one:
| - Fever 94% - General Malaise 78% - Cough 47% - Giveable 42% - Artromialgias 41% - Migraine 34% - Pain Pleuri'tico 25% |
Expectoracio'n 23% Nauseas 19% Hemoptisis 6% Confusion 6% Dayable 4% Agitation 2% Other 16% |
The demonstrated clinical signs were:
| - objetivada Fever 91% - Crepitantes 64% - Sibilancias 14% - Youable 9% - Cyanosis 6% |
- Hepatomegalia 4% - Adenopati'as 1% - Haveable Theable 1% - Ofable Eruption. 0% - Other 8% |
Between the analytical data of interest it is possible to emphasize the
following ones:
| - Anemia (Hb - Leukocyteable - Creatinina - Hiponatremia - Ldh - Ggt - F. Alcalina |
<11gr%) 11% (>15.000/mm3) 18% (>2mg/dl) 8% (Na<130mOsm/L) 6% (>500 Ui/l) 23% - Gpt (>100 Ui/l) 5% (>100 Ui/l) 16% (>300ui/l) 18% |
The average number of leukocytes was 11.850 able and the average value of mable creatinina 1,29.
The gasometricos analyses revealed the following results:
- pO2>45MMHg 6%
- pO2<65mmHg 55%
- pO2<60mmHg 36%
- Gradient Alveolo-arterial>45 17%
- Gradient Alveolo-arterial>60 2%
The average values of pO2, pO2 and of alveolo-arterial Gradiente were
respectively of 37.84mmHg, 63.53mmHg and 34.55.
The radiological data more substitutes were the following ones:
- Radiological Pattern: to
*Alveolar 89%
*Intersticial 6%
*Mixto 6%
- Radiological Extension: to *Unilobar 82%
*Multilobar able. 8% to
*Multilobar bable. 10%
- Radiological Affectation: inferior *Lobulos 67%
(izdo. 51%, dcho. 49%)
*Lobulos superior 38% (izdo. 45%, dcho. 55%)
*Lobulo means 13%
- pleural Spill:
*Sin spills 89% *Unilateral 10%
*Bilateral 1%
Evolution of the cases
From the moment of the beginning of the symptoms to the one of the attendance
in the Hospital Prince of Asturias 4,3 days passed like average. The clinical
improvement after the treatment also took place in 4.3 days like average, being
good in general the macroidos answer to the treatment with. Objectiveable three
reingresos in hospitalization: one of them, who evolved favourably, with
pathology related not clearly to the pneumonico process, a second case of 92
years that passed away with suspicion of added broncoaspiracion and a third case
of 70 years that reingreso in septica situation and I fail multiorganic, passing
away later by secondary septico shock to pseudomembranosa colitis, considera
dose like a complication of the antibiotic treatment.
Of the 224 cases included in the outbreak, 9 passed away, which throws a rate
of 4% lethality, habitually referred inferior number to for these outbreaks. The
average age of the deceaseds was of 71,2 years (rank 41-91). All of them
presented/displayed significant pluripatologi. The discrepancy between the
present number of deceaseds and the one that occurred as official when
finalizing the outbreak (15 deceaseds) also obeys to that this one last,
provisional one, she has been corrected when applying the definitive criteria of
inclusion of case, descartadose of the cases of the outbreak 6 deceaseds who did
not fulfil such criteria.
Characteristics of person
The average age of the total of cases was of 59,3 (s=18.3), being 62,7 (s=13)
for the confirmed cases, 60 (s=16.7) for probable cases and 55,4 (s=22.5) for
the suspicious cases. The analysis of the variance of these three averages
reveals a significant difference (p<0.05) between the average of confirmed cases
and the one of suspects.
Figure 1 shows the specific rates by age for the total of cases and by sexes.
It can clearly estimable that the incidence increases progressively as of the 54
years and that the age group more affected is the one of 70-79 years. The
distribution is similar for men and women, being the rates of these inferior
ones in all the affected groups of age more, safe in the one of 70-74, in which
he is slightly superior to the one of men.
Figure 1. - Rates of incidence you specify by age and sex for the total of
cases.
The 58,5% of the total of cases were men and the 41,5% women, being the
specific rates by sex, standardized by age and for all the population of Alcala
de Henares, 164,9 by 100,000 inhabitants for men and 103,9 for women, and the
masculineable reason of 1.59. If we analyzed the masculineable reason of for
cases separately confirmed, probable and suspicious, we observed that for the
confirmed cases the reason descends to 1,15, being 1,8 and 2 for the probable
and suspicious cases, respectively.
In addition to the age average outpost, the registered more important factors
of risk between the antecedents of the cases were: $able - Tabaquismo 32% -
Hepatopati'a 5% - EPOC 23% - Inmunosupresion nonVIH 1,3% - Cardiopathy 22% -
Other 23% Alcoholism 10% In relation to the professional activity of the cases
the most frequent groups were Workings domestic (24.2%) and Retired (18.8%).
Temporary-space distribution
Figure 2 shows the temporary distribution of all the cases and the cases
confirmed, according to date of beginning of symptoms.
In 17 cases the date could not be known beginning of symptoms, reason why
they are not represented in the figure. It can esteemable which the outbreak
stops the total of cases seems to present/display two phases of different
intensity, being second, between days 15 of September and 5 of October, of
greater intensity. Nevertheless, when single considering the confirmed cases the
appearance of the same ones is more homogenous in the time. The last confirmed
case began with symptoms on day 11 of October.

Figure 2.
Temporary distribution of the total of cases and the
confirmed cases, according to date of beginning of symptoms.
From the beginning of the investigation
epidemiologist of the outbreak a clear space aggregation of cases in the North
zone of the municipality was observed, in agreement with its direction of
residence.
For objectable such aggregation the rates of censusable incidence by sections
of Alcala de Henares have calculated, standardized by age.
Figure nº 3 shows the graphical representation of these rates
for all pneumonia studied during the outbreak, with microbiological criteria of
confirmation for Legionella. In her it can observeable how the sections
censusable with elevated rates of incidence more are located in the North zone
of the municipality.
Since in addition, all the patients with pneumonia and microbiological
criterion of confirmation who lived outside the North zone, been had exposed to
that zone in the three previous weeks in the beginning of his disease, with the
exception of two, he was decided to delimit this North zone as zone of risk and
of including the exhibition to the same one as criterion epidemiologist of
inclusion of case.

Figure 3.
Rates of incidence of pneumonia with microbiological criterion
of censusable confirmation po sections, standardized by age
Figure 4 shows the rates of censusable incidence by sections for all the
cases incluidos in the outbreak.
The distribution of cases is similar to the one of previous Figure. The
sections censusable with elevated rates of incidence more are located grouped in
a zone between Complutensian Via, the line of the railroad and the O´Donnell
Park.
Figure 4.
Rates of incidence of total cases of the outbreakof
censusable legionellosis by sections, standardized by age
MICROBIOLOGICAL RESULTS
In this section the microbiological results of the studies
appear on human samples. In the section corresponding to the environmental
investigation the microbiological results of the analyzed water samples will
appear. In the studies of isolation of Legionella 9 isolated of L.s pneumophila
SG1, samples coming from 7 cases recovered: 7 samples, coming from 5 patients,
obtained by broncoscopia, 1 of beable one and 1 of pulmonary weave coming from
autopsy. All of them belonged to the sub-group greater Pontiac, sub-group
smaller Knoxville. Of the 7 cases with isolation of Legionella, 4 agree with
serolo'gicos data diagnoses (one of them in addition with positive positive PCR
and 2 with antigenuria) 1 with suggestive serologicos data (seroconversion to
1/64), 1 with positive negative serologicos data and PCR, and one rest in which
it was not had another type of sample. In the serologicos studies the following
positive or suggestive results of recent infection by L. were obtained
pneumophila: Seroconversion to ³1/128 49 cases - Seroconversion to 1/64 10 cases
- Title unique or maintained ³1/256 40 cases - maintained Title =1/128 15 cases
In the studies of detection of antigen of L. pneumophila in orable positive
results in 37 cases were obtained. In 23 of them also positive results by other
diagnosticas techniques (isolation, serologia or PCR) and in the 14 rest were
obtained antigenuria was the only diagnostica test of laboratory. The tests of
detection of genomic material by enzymatic amplification of DNA gave positive
results in 12 cases. In 9 of them also positive results by other diagnosticas
techniques were obtained and in the 3 rest the technique of the PCR was the
unique one that showed a positive result.
All the samples analyzed with the technique of direct immunofluorescence gave
negative results.
ENVIRONMENTAL INVESTIGATION
After the first clinical data and epidemiologists made the
hypothesis probable of a legionellosis outbreak, the environmental investigation
began. Given evident to the space grouping of cases in the North zone of the
municipality and the absence of common exhibition from those to closed places of
public concurrence, the environmental investigation went fundamentally to the
location in this zone of potential emitting centers of Legionella, able to emit
aerosols to the public route, and the detection in same of the stock the cause
of the outbreak. Also one studied the potable water network of the zone, as well
as other facilities of storage and water distribution for public use
(centralized sanitary hot water, wells, etc.), with the purpose of identifying,
to where outside possible, the origin of the outbreak and in general the
presence of environmental factors of risk which they could contribute to explain
that one.
Table 2 presents/displays all the water samples taken in the investigation
from the outbreak, according to its the positive origin, as well as number of
studied facilities and results for samples and facilities. A total of 109
samples coming from 85 different facilities was taken, being positive to
Legionella 46% of the samples and 45% of the facilities. More the frequently
contaminated facilities were the cooling towers, detectandose presence of
Legionella in a 63% of the same ones, and the water tanks of communities of
neighbours (5 contaminated deposits of 7 studied, 71%).
| Origin of the samples | Nº samples / Nº facilities |
positive Samples / positive Facilities |
| Tower Refrigeration | 63/41 | 38/26 |
| Sanitary Water Diffusing Deposit |
17/15 7/7 |
4/4 5/5 |
| Terminal network | 4/4 | 1/1 |
| washing cars | 5/5 | 0 |
| Well | 6/6 | 1/1 |
| Tanker | 2/2 | 1/1 |
| Source | 1/1 | 0 |
| Other | 4/4 | 0 |
| Total | 109/85 | 50/38 |
Table 2. Isolations of Legionella in environmental samples of Alcala de Henares
In Table 3 are the results of the identification of the isolated ones.
From the 50 water samples with positive isolation isolated ones of Legionella
were obtained 53, since in three cooling towers two different species or
serogroups were identified. The 53 isolated ones were identified as it follows:
49 (92.5%) of species L. pneumophila
4 of different species (2 L.s micdadei, 1 L. bozemanii / L. longbeachae SG2,
and 1 Legionella sp).
Of the 49 isolated of L. pneumophila, 42 (86%) belonged to the SG1, and the 7
rest to other different serogroups. Of the 42 isolated of L pneumophila SG1, 12
belonged to the sub-group greater Pontiac (8 to the sub-group smaller Knoxville
and 4 to the sub-group smaller Benidorm) and the 30 rest belonged to the
sub-group greater Olda, all of them of the sub-group smaller Oxford/Camperdown.

Table 3. Distribution of the isolated ones in species of Legionable, serogrupos of L. pneumophila and sub-groups of L. pneumophila Sg 1.
Figure 5
presents/displays the results obtained in first samples (excluding second and
successive samples) according to its origin, detallandose the negative results
and the distribution of the isolated ones by species, serogroups and sub-group.
From 85 first samples they were positive to Legionella 37 (43.5%). The
cooling towers were positive in 61% of the samples.

Figure 5: Results of isolation of Legionella in first samples according to his origin
Those isolated ones identified like L. pneumophila SG1, sub-group greater
Pontiac, sub-group smaller Knoxville (9 of human origin and 8 of environmental
origin:
4 cooling towers and 2 deposits of communities of neighbours) were studied by
the techniques of molecular Biology of chain reaction of polymerase (PCR
arbitrary) and electroforesis in field pressed after digestion of the DNA with
two enzymes of restriction, Not I and Sfi I. Both techniques demonstrated the
identity of the two groups of isolated.
Figure 6 shows the location in Alcala de Henares of the 4 cooling towers
and the 2 water tanks contaminated with L. pneumophila SG1, sub-group greater
Pontiac, sub-group smaller Knoxville. The tower number 1 and the two deposits
are located in the zone of maximum incidence of the disease.

Figure 6.
Location in Alcala de Henares of the cooling towers and water
tanks contaminated by L. pneumophila SG1, greater sub-group
Pontiac, sub-group smaller Knoxville
The study of the potable water network, specially of the North
zone, showed the presence of important sanitary, structural deficiencies and
functional, that drew trasfondo I cause to explain the contamination of the
cooling towers: Presence of numerous water tanks of Communities of Vecinos (more
than 2000 in Alcala de Henares and 719 in the North zone) that, generally, had
deficient conditions of cleaning and, given its characteristics, they cause
retentions of the water during periods prolonged of time and ebb tides to the
network. - Presence of numerous terminal points of network (13 in the North
zone), some of them with low or null values of chlorine after the
superchlorination of the network and drained presence of turbidity and dirt to
the being manual Chlorine in some of the municipal deposits (deposits of Meco).
nonhomogenous Distribution of chlorine in the network (important oscillations of
the free residual chlorine level in different points from the network).
ANALYSIS EPIDEMIOLOGIST
According to one commented in the methodology section, two complementary types
of study with the purpose of establishing associations between the exhibition to
diverse environmental factors of risk and the fact were designed of suffering
one pneumonia by Legionella.
Table 4
presents/displays the results of the analysis of design 1 (cases of pneumonia
with microbiological criterion of confirmation for Legionella as opposed to the
rest of pneumonia like controls). Or for each variable have calculated fit by
sex and age by means of logistic regression.
A statistically significant association between living in the delimited zone is
demonstrated as on visitable risk or and to be case, OR=15.7 (3,7-66.2).
When analysing the exhibition to the cooling towers, is a statistically
significant association between exhibition to tower 1 and to be case, OR=3.14
(1.8-5.5), and between the exhibition to tower 4 and to be case, OR=2.02
(1.2-3.5).
Analysing only the visits to the circles of the cases that live outside them,
they continue being significant the associations between being case and of
visiting tower 1, OR=3.48 (1.9-6.5), or of visiting tower 4, OR=2.04 (1.2-3.6).
Or, fit by age have calculated in addition and sex, of the exhibition to I
circulate 1 and to I circulate 4, controlling the possible effect of the
interaction between both, manteniendose the associations commented previously,
with values of Or for tower 1 of 3.95 (1,90-8,23) and for tower 4 of 2.85
(1,12-7,29).
Significant associations for the rest of studied factors of environmental risk
have not been detected.



TABLE EXHIBITION WITH ISOLATION OF L. PNEUMOPHILA SG1 SUB-GROUP GREATER PONTIAC SUB-GROUP SMALLER KNOXVILLE
Table 5
presents/displays the results of design 2 (cases of pneumonia with clinical
criteria of inclusion in the outbreak, entered 8 of October, as opposed to cases
entered next dates with diagnosis different from pneumonia).
In this study significant association between living in the zone of visitable
risk or and to be case OR=6,25 (2,06-25,5), and between the exhibition to tower
1 has also been demonstrated and to be case OR=5.18 (1.76-18.45). Significant
association with the exhibition to tower 4 has not been demonstrated
nevertheless, although the association is in the limit of the meaning, nor with
other factors of risk.

Like complementary approach to the commented designs, 100
and 200 meters circles of and 200 and 300 meter calculated in addition the gross
rates to population incidence of pneumonia with microbiological criteria of
confirmation for Legionella in a radius of 100 meters around the four towers and
in the sectors between.
Table 6 shows the results of these calculations. It can esteemable that
around tower 1 occurs the elevated rates of incidence more and than a decreasing
gradient of incidence exists as we moved away of the same one, which does not
happen in the other towers.

Table 6.
Incidence of cases of neumoni'a with microbiological criteria of
confirmation around
the contaminated cooling towers with L.pneumophila SG1, sub-group greater
Pontiac, sub-group smaller Knoxville
The results reviewed epidemiologists, together with the microbiological or commented data, indicate as origin of the outbreak to one or several cooling towers. These facilities have been cause of outbreaks of the same nature in numerous occasions, according to gathers scientific Literature
MEASURES OF CONTROL
Day 23 of September communicated by telephone to Centro de Public Salud of
Alcala de Henares, on the part of National Center of Microbiology, the finding
of 5 high titles (³1/256) of antibodies and one seroconversion to Legionella
pneumophila SG1, in patients entered by pneumonia in the Hospital Prince of
Asturias.
Since, in addition, these findings agreed with the most probable hypothesis
that until that date they sustained to the clinical data and epidemiologists, it
was decided as opposed to to dictate immediately preventive measures for the
population of Alcala de Henares legionellosis.
The first measures were of general character, destined to avoid the formation
of aerosols in the home (to avoid the shower and the domestic pulverization of
water) and in places public (to avoid the irrigation by aspersion, the
irrigation of streets in hours of public concurrence, to paralyse the ornamental
operation of sources and the one of systems of refrigeration of water and air
conditioning by water...), to the time that began the active search, in the
North zone of Alcala de Henares, device and cooling towers, in general, or
system of refrigeration and air conditioning that could cause aerosols. These
measures were spread through a municipal side.
The superchlorination of the network was carried out until reaching a minimum
of 3 ppm of residual free chlorine in all the points of that one, during a non
inferior time to 8 hours. Later the chlorine stayed around 2 ppm until the
remission of the outbreak. The cleaning of the cooling towers of the North zone
of Alcala de Henares determined day 26th of September. Since census of the same
ones did not exist, it was necessary to make an exhaustive active search,
identification of 23 towers, that were cleaned and disinfected or sealed between
days 30th of September and 7th of October. Between such towers were the
identified ones in this report like towers 1, 2, 3 and 4, contaminating with L.
pneumophila SG1, sub-group greater Pontiac, sub-group smaller Knoxville.
Between days 10 and 12 of October one second cleaning of the towers by
specially qualified companies was carried out, like additional guarantee.
The purge and cleaning of terminal points of the potable water network
(blind points) and the cleaning and disinfection of water tanks of Communities
of Vecinos, were carried out after knowing the existence these points of risk in
the municipal network.
The cleaning of sanitary hot water tanks centralized and the extension of the
cleaning of water tanks and cooling towers to all the municipality, were
determined in later dates also like measures of additional guarantee.
According to it can estimable in Figure 7 these measures of control were
adopted in early dates, the great majority of them before definitive the
etiologica confirmation of the outbreak by the Committee of Experts.

Figure 7.
Preventive measures dictated by Director
Gable de Prevencio'n and Promocio'n of Salud
CONCLUSIONS
1. - The epidemic outbreak of pneumonia happened in September and October of 1996 in the city of Alcala de Henares was caused by the Legionella bacterium pneumophila SG1, sub-group greater Pontiac, sub-group smaller Knoxville.
2-of the 224 cases including in the outbreak, 92 (41.1%) correspond to confirmed cases, 42 (18.8%) to probable cases and 90 (40.1%) to suspicious cases.
3. - The initial hypothesis of work that oriented the clinical handling of the patients and the medical treatment precociously established, conditioned, to demonstrate the guessed right thing of that one, the favourable general evolution to the treatment in few days, being the rate of lethality caused by this outbreak (4%) more loss than the habitual one in outbreaks of the same nature.
4. - The results of the investigations epidemiologist, microbiological and environmental agree in indicating as origin of the outbreak to one or several cooling towers of water, contaminated with the same stock of Legionella found in the patients. The sanitary deficiencies of the network of potable water supply have been able to play a facilitate able role in the appearance of the outbreak.
5. - At sight of the evolution of the outbreak, the preventive measures, adopted quickly, demonstrated their effectiveness in the control of that one.
6-with the aim to integrate the diverse health actions, directed in his different slopes from the investigation and control of the outbreak, it was necessary to establish precise mechanisms of technical and institutional coordination that worked correctly.
ANNEXED
Preventive Actions Forehead To New Outbreaks of Legionella
Once personal the outbreaks of legionellosis of Alcala de Henares, the
actions of Public Salud was oriented in two fundamental lines: to maintain
activated the devices of Vigilancia Epidemiologist before the eventuality of any
new case of the disease and of developing to preventive measures forehead to
possible new outbreaks
The devices of Vigilancia Epidemiologist have stayed in alert uninterruptedly
from the remission of the outbreak to the present time, and will remain at least
in alert to the next winter. Its objective is precociously to detect the
appearance of possible new cases of legionellosis, with the purpose of taking
part as rapidly as possible. Given the characteristics of the past it appears,
is logical that the information for the monitoring obtains from the Hospital
Prince of Asturias, where were taken care of 96% of the cases of that one. Thus,
one has arranged that this Hospital communicates to Service of Public Salud of
Area III the following information: Periodic 1.-Notificacio'n (two times per
week or exceptionally in case of suspicion) of all pneumonia taken care of
(entered or not) with specification of
Name and Last names of the patient.
Date of attention in emergencies. -
Date of birth.
Address.
Diagnosis in Emergencies.
Derivation of the patient.
From this information, and with the purpose of detecting non awaited
groups in the time or the space, the incidence and weekly tendency of pneumonia
in Alcala de Henares study, comparadolas with the rest of Area III, with
observed in the same city years 1993-1996 (epidemic channel of pneumonia) and
with the observed thing at the present time and previous years in the geographic
zone taken care of by a Hospital of reference in Madrid, like the Gregorio
Mara6no'n.
One separately studies the incidence and evolution of the pediatricos cases
(where the legionellosis is little frequent) with respect to the cases in
adults. Also the place of residence of the cases studies, distribution in a map
of the city.
Urgent 2.-Notification of any positive or suggestive microbiological result
of recent infection by Legionella known by the Hospital, with the purpose of
making the survey pertinent epidemiologist to the case and of investigating the
possible source of infection.
The information analyzed by these devices of monitoring epidemiologist allows
to affirm that to date the incidence of pneumonias is within the awaited thing
and there has been no sprout again of the disease in Alcala de Henares.
Preventive measures
Given the possibility, frequently documented in scientific Literature, of appearance of a new outbreak of legionellosis in Alcala de Henares, specially in the months of summer-autumn, when the climatic conditions are more appropriate for it, from the remission of the past it appears has worked intensely in developing a series of tending preventive measures to avoid, in all the possible one, the appearance of that one. The actions made in that sense are the following ones:
1. - Maintenance outside operation of the 6 contaminated cooling towers, during the investigation of the past appears, with Legionella pneumophila SG1, sub-group greater Pontiac, located in the denominated zone of risk (North zone of the municipality) or the next environs, given the implication of the same ones in the origin of the outbreak. These towers could again be put into operation, once fulfilled the requirements established by General Direction of Prevention and Promotion of Salud of Consejeria of Health and Social Services.
2.-Comunicacio'n to the City council of Alcala de Henares of the measures
to adopt in relation to the system of potable water supply of its municipality,
including: automatic
2.1-Cloracio'n in all the municipal deposits.
2.2.-Mantenimiento of the residual free chlorine levels in all the points of the network in 1.2-1.5 ppm. Continuous and automatic
2.3.-Drenaje of the testable one of the network until a complete one of the same one is made badlyable.
2.4.-Maintenance out of service of the municipal device of water pick up of Smokeable.
2.5.-Estudio in depth of the system of supplying and specifically of relative to pressures of the network and the losses of water, deposits of communities of neighbours, location of points with low or null speeds (testable) and quality of the water in distitos points of the network. All it with the purpose of detecting nonasumibles risks in the network of eliminateable distribution and.
3.-Contract of the services of a qualified company, with the purpose of making a study of evaluation of sanitary risks of the systems or processes of interchange air-water that aerosols generate (evaporative cooling towers, condensers and others) in Alcala de Henares, as well as of the system of potable water supply of this municipality, with specific recommendations (protocols and technical directives of action) for the elimination of the detected risks. The study was made during the February-April months and at the present time already it has been given.
4.-Creation of a Technical Group of Trabajo in Prevention de Legionella in the Community of Madrid, integrated by technicians of General Direction of Prevention and Promotion of Salud and General Direction of Industrial, and Associations of technicians and industrialists related to the maintenance and disinfection of air conditioning facilities and refrigeration. The assignment of this Group has been to review, from the different sectors, enterprise technicians and, the most appropriate boarding (in its slopes technical, operative and legal) for the control of sanitary risks related to the Legionella.
5.-Elaboracio'n of a Resolution of General Director of Prevention and
Promotion of Salud, on hygienic conditions that must reunite the evaporative
cooling towers, condensers and other devices of interchange air-water, in the
municipality of Alcala de Henares. This resolution will be public shortly and
contemplates, in relation to the mentioned facilities, the following aspects:
Characteristic techniques. -
Location and height of unloading. -
Maintenance, cleaning and disinfection, before its beginning, whenever been
it has stopped a time. -
Treatment and quality of the water. -
Book of incidences. -
Products to use in the cleaning and disinfection. -
enabled Companies to make the maintenance, cleaning and disinfection. -
Sanctions.
Complementarily to the measures adopted by General Direction of Prevention
and Promotion of Salud, the City council of Alcala de Henares has approved a
regulating Decree of the hygienic conditions of cleaning and of the water tanks
of the communities of proprietors.
Once made Resolution public of General Direction of Prevention and Promotion
of Salud, and as I complement to the monitoring devices epidemiologist of
pneumonia in Alcala de Henares, a device of microbiological monitoring of the
water of the facilities with interchange will also be started air-water that
generate aerosols, with the purpose of detecting and precociously eliminating
possible sanitary risks derived from the contamination of those by Legionella
and to evaluate in addition the effectiveness degree of the propose cogoverning
measures by Resoluction.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Mitchell E, O'Mahony M, Watson JM, et. al. Two outbreaks of Legionnaires' disease in Bolton Health District. Epidemiol Infect 1990;104:159-170.
Klaucke DN, Voogt RL, LaRue D, et al. Legionnaries' disease: the epidemiology of two outbreaks in Burlington, Vermont, 1980. Am J Epidemiol 1984; 119:382-91. . Edelstein PH . Improved semiselective medium for isolation of Legionella pneumophila from contaminated clinical and environmental specimens. J Clin Microbiol 1981; 14:298-303. .
Edelstein PH, Snitzer JB, Bridge JA. Enhancement of recovery of Legionella pneumophila from contaminated respiratory tract specimens by heat. J Clin Microbiol 1982; 16: 1061-1065.
Bopp CA, Summer JW, Morris GK et al. Isolation of Legionella spp from environmental water samples by low pH treatment and use of a selective medium. J Clin Microbiol 1981; 13: 714-719.
Pelaz C, García L, Martín Bourgon C. Legionellae isolated from clinical and environmental samples in Spain (1983-1990): monoclonal typing of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates. Epidemiol Infec 1992;108:397-402.
Watkins ID, Tobin JOH, Dennis PJ et al. Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 subgrouping by monoclonal antibodies. An epidemiological tool. J Hyg 1985; 95:211-216. .
Joly JR, McKinney RM, Tobin JO et al. Development of a atandardized subgrouping scheme for Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 using monoclonal antibodies. J Clin Microbiol 1986;23:768-771.
Kessier HH, Reinthaler FF, Fschaid A et al. Rapid detection of Legionella species in bronchoalveolar fluids with the EnviroAmp Legionella PCR Amplification kit. J Clin Microbiol 1993;31(12):3325-3328. .
Cianciotto NP, Bangsborg JM, Eisenstein BI et al. Identification of mip-like genes in the genus Legionella. Infect Immun 1990;58(9):2912-2918 .
Grist NR, Bell EJ, Follet EA et al. Diagnostic methods in clinical virology, 3ª ed. Blackwell Scientific Publications. Oxford, 1979.
Edelstein PH. Comparative study of selective media for isolation of Legionella pneumophila from potable water. J Clin Microbiol 1982;16:697-699. .
Watson JM, Mitchel E, Gabbay J et al. Picadilly Circus legionnaire´s disease outbreak. J Publ Health Med 1994;16(3):341-347. .
, CW, Breiman RF. Advances in the epidemiology and control of Legionella infections. Epidemiol Rev 1991;13:329-340.
Gómez Lus P, Fields BS, Benson RF et al. Comparison of arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction, ribotyping and monoclonal antibodies analysis for subtyping Legionella pneumophila SG1. J Clin Microbiol 1993;31:1940-1942
Lück PC, Bender L, Ott M et al. Analysis of Legionella pneumophila SG6 strains isolated from a hospital warm water supply over a three year period by using genomic long range mapping techniques and monoclonal antibodies. Appl Environ Microbiol 1991;57:3226-3231.
Pruckler JM, Mermel LA, Benson RF et al. Comparison of Legionella pneumophila isolates by arbitrarily primed PCR and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis: analysis from seven epidemic investigations. J Clin Microbiol 1995;33:2872-2875.
Addis D, Davis JP, Laventure M et al. Community-acquired legionnaires´disease associated with a cooling tower: evidence for longer-distance transpor of Legionella pneumophila. Am J Epidemiol 1989;130(3):557-568. .
Garbe PL, Davis BJ, Weisfeld JS et al. Nosocomial legionnaires´disease: epidemiologic demonstration of cooling towers as a source. JAMA 1985;254:521-524
Dondero TJ, Rendtorff RC, Mallison GF et al. An outbreak of legionnaires´ disease associated with a contaminated air conditioning cooling tower. N Engl J Med 1980;302:365-370
Email
Denis Green
legion@q-net.net.au