Legionellais a Gram negativebacterium,
including many species that cause legionellosis or Legionaires' disease, most
notably L. pneumophilia. At least 46
species
and 70 serogroups
have been identified. On the side-chains
of the cell wall
are carried the bases for the somatic antigen specifity of these organisms. The
chemical composition of these side chains both with respect to components as
well as arrangement of the different sugars determines the nature of the somatic
or O antigen determinants, which are such important means of serologically
classifying many Gram-negative bacteria.
At least 14 different serovars
of L. pneumophila have been described as well as several other species
being subdivided into a number of serovars.
Sera
have been used both for slide agglutination studies as well as for direct
detection of bacteria in tissues using fluorescent-labelled
antibody.
Specific antibody in patients can be determined by the indirect fluorescent
antibody test.
ELISA
and microagglutination tests have also been successfully applied.
L. pneumophila
is an intracellular pathogen. The internalisation of the bacteria is enhanced by
the presence of antibody
and complement.
A pseudopod
coils around the bacterium in this unique form of phagocytosis.
Once internalised, the bacteria surround themselves by a membrane-bound phagolysosome.
This becomes a vesicle,
within which the bacteria multiply. They produce a 39kDa metalloprotease
into culture fluids, which is cytotoxic for some cultured tissue culture cells.
Special
Note
Legionella is a bacteria not a virus, it has an
incubation period now of up to 20 days.
Two recent outbreaks in France and
Norway it was stated that the legionella travelled 12 and 17 Kilometres
Public health officials are investigating the deaths of four people from a
"typical respiratory illness" at an east-end senior's residence, but say the
outbreak is not SARS.
The four victims were residents at the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged in the
city's east end, said Dr. Barbara Yaffe, Toronto Public Health's director of
communicable disease control.
"We know from the testing that's been done so far that this is not influenza,
we know this is not SARS, we know this is not avian influenza," said Dr. Allison
McGeer, infectious disease consultant at Toronto's Mount Sinai Hospital.
"There are many other viruses it could be ... and the Ontario Public Health
lab is working very hard on identifying which one of those viruses it might be."
The unidentified illness has affected 68 residents and five employees at
facility.
Three of the victims died at the home while the fourth died in hospital, she
said.
Dr. Yaffe said all of the four victims had severe pre-existing medical
conditions. Two were in their 90s, another in the late 70s, and the fourth in
the 50s.
She said outbreaks are typical but this one set off alarms because of its
severity.
"We get hundreds of outbreaks every year, however in this situation we do
have a particularly serious outbreak," Dr. Yaffe said.
She said 15 people have been admitted to hospitals in the area, but are not
being quarantined.
"There is no quarantine necessary for this," Dr. Yaffe said, and emphasized
that there was no threat to the greater public.
The speed with which the illness spread led Dr. McGeer to speculate whether a
presence of bacteria within the home contributed to the outbreak.
Dr. Yaffe also added that while this outbreak was serious, it was not the
worst in recent memory. Last year, 11 people died after an outbreak at a Cobourg,
Ont., nursing home, she said.
CFTO News reported that the first signs of the most recent illness were
detected Tuesday, but no residents were taken to hospital until Saturday night.
Dozens of family members were prevented from entering the home Saturday.
Emergency room staff at Centenary Hospital donned gowns and masks Saturday as
a procedural precaution — a standard practice in Ontario hospitals after the
SARS outbreak in 2003.
Either people haven't been following precautions that we are supposed to follow
now for all people with fever or respiratory illness . . . or alternatively,
somebody had brought it in from the community to the nursing home and they
weren't really that sick from it," infectious disease specialist Dr. Neil Rau
said.
Symptoms of the illness include fever, cough, runny nose, and malaise, Dr.
McGeer said.
She said the best way for the public to prevent such outbreaks occurring is to
wash their hands thoroughly and frequently.
October 3, 2005 Media Advisory - Respiratory illness update
Toronto Public Health continues to investigate the outbreak of respiratory
illness at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged, Dr. David McKeown, Toronto's Medical
Officer of Health, said today.
The investigation is being carried out in conjunction with the Ministry of
Health and Long-Term Care, the Ontario Public Health Laboratory, the Coroner's
Office and affected hospitals. The outbreak began September 25, 2005.
Dr. McKeown reported the following update:
The outbreak has affected a total of 68 residents so far, eight employees
and three visitors at Seven Oaks.
There have been no new cases since yesterday, but there have been two
additional deaths, for a total of six in the outbreak.
The majority of cases are improving but some have worsened as the illness
takes its course.
Thirty residents from Seven Oaks have been admitted to hospital.
Toronto Public Health staff have followed up with 170 contacts connected
to Seven Oaks. This includes families of children who attend the adjacent day
nursery.
Testing continues to determine the cause of the illness.
Hospitals and their emergency rooms are operating normally.
Some additional precautions are being taken in the emergency room at the
Centenary site of Rouge Valley to protect patients and staff.
October 4, 2005 Media Advisory - Respiratory illness update
The respiratory illness at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged has resulted in
additional deaths among ill residents, but the outbreak remains under control,
Dr. David McKeown, Toronto’s Medical Officer of Health, reported today.
Dr. McKeown provided the following update:
Since yesterday there have been four additional deaths, for a total of ten
in the outbreak.
The outbreak has so far affected a total of 70 residents, 12 employees and
two visitors at Seven Oaks.
40 residents from Seven Oaks have been admitted to hospital.
The majority of cases are improving but some have worsened as the illness
takes its course.
Testing continues to determine the cause of the illness.
Hospitals and their emergency rooms are operating normally.
"Although the condition of some ill residents has worsened and unfortunately
four more have died, others are improving and we are confident this outbreak is
under control," said Dr. McKeown.
Dr. McKeown will hold a media briefing this afternoon.
Date: Tuesday, October 4
Time: 4 p.m.
Location: Room 502, 277 Victoria St. (corner of Dundas St. E., one block east of
Yonge St.)
Date: Tue, 4 Oct 2005 13:06:00 -0400
From: Jeannette Macey <Jeannette_Macey
TA phac-aspc.gc.ca
& Susan Squires, (Public Health Agency of Canada) & the Ontario Ministry
of Health and Long Term Care
By way of further follow-up to the 3 Oct 2005 posting entitled "Undiagnosed
respiratory deaths - Canada (ON): RFI", I am providing the following summary
from the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long Term Care and the Public Health
Agency of Canada.
The province of Ontario has in place ongoing surveillance for febrile
respiratory illnesses in hospitals and residential institutions. The syndrome
under surveillance is referred to as febrile respiratory illness or FRI. As a
result of this ongoing surveillance, outbreaks are regularly detected,
especially during the influenza/respiratory virus season, which we are now
entering in Canada. The 1st outbreak of laboratory-confirmed influenza for
2005-2006 was reported in a long-term care facility (LTCF) elsewhere in the
country last week, and other common respiratory viruses are circulating as well.
(see Canada's weekly FluWatch surveillance report at:
<http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/fluwatch/index.html)>)
The important summary points re: public health significance of this outbreak are
that preliminary laboratory results are negative for key respiratory
pathogens of concern (including influenza viruses, novel influenza viruses, SARS
as well as other common respiratory pathogens); the attack rate and mortality
rate are not out of the expected range for LTCF outbreaks, and finally the
outbreak appears to be waning (no new cases in recent days). Further laboratory
investigations are ongoing.
The current outbreak of FRI was identified in a Toronto nursing home on Tue 27
Sep 2005. A FRI case is defined as a resident, staff member or visitor
with sudden onset of fever with malaise and/or anorexia, with or without runny
nose and congestion or cough.
To date, 67/249 (27 percent) residents and 8/290 (3 percent) staff members meet
the case definition (these numbers are subject to change); 23 (34
percent) resident-cases and 1 (13 percent) staff-case have been hospitalized. 6
(9 percent) case-residents have died. Additionally, 3 visitors have been
identified who meet the case definition; 2 of these have been hospitalized and
investigated.
Cases are rapidly improving upon initiation of antibiotic therapy. Despite
comprehensive preliminary testing for bacterial and viral respiratory
pathogens, no organism has yet been identified. Lung biopsy specimens from
deceased cases are undergoing testing. Several prevention and control
strategies have been implemented, and the outbreak appears to be waning, with
many cases now improving. There have been new cases reported since midnight 2
Oct [2005]. The risk of transmission to the general public would appear to be
minimal.
In terms of the larger picture with respect to the respiratory [illness] season
in Canada, we are likely to see many reports of nursing home and other
institutional outbreaks. As is often the case, a proportion of these outbreaks
will not have any identifiable etiologic agent. Using increasingly
sophisticated molecular testing techniques, laboratory scientists are able to
detect and identify previously unrecognizable viruses, e.g. new coronaviruses
and parvoviruses etc. As a result, appropriate risk assessment is an important
accompaniment to these reports, especially given the current very wide coverage
of respiratory illnesses/outbreaks in the media.
Jeannette Macey
A/Head of Disease Surveillance
Immunization and Respiratory Infections Division (IRID)
Division d'immunisation et des infections respiratoires (DIIR)
Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC)
Agence de sante publique du Canada (ASPC)
Building #6, AL 0602D, Tunney's Pasture
Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0L2
<Jeannette_Macey TA phac-aspc.gc.ca>
Respiratory illness update
TORONTO, October. 4
The respiratory illness at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged has resulted in additional deaths among ill residents, but the
outbreak remains under control, Dr. David McKeown, Toronto's Medical Officer of Health, reported today.
Dr. McKeown provided the following update:
- Since yesterday there have been four additional deaths,for a total of ten in the outbreak.
- The outbreak has so far affected a total of 70 residents,12 employees and two visitors at Seven Oaks.
- 40 residents from Seven Oaks have been admitted to hospital.
- The majority of cases are improving but some have worsened as the illness takes its course.
- Testing continues to determine the cause of the illness.
- Hospitals and their emergency rooms are operating normally.
"Although the condition of some ill residents has worsened and unfortunately four more have died, others are improving and we are confident
this outbreak is under control," said Dr. McKeown.
October 5, 2005 Media Advisory - Respiratory illness update
The respiratory illness at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged has resulted in six
additional deaths among ill residents, Dr. David McKeown, Toronto’s Medical
Officer of Health, reported today.
“The six new deaths are not new cases. All of these elderly individuals had been
previously identified as cases and had underlying medical conditions,” Dr.
McKeown said. “There have been no new reported cases in the last 24 hours.”
Dr. McKeown provided the following update:
There have been six additional deaths, for a total of 16 in the outbreak.
The outbreak has so far affected 70 residents, 13 employees and five
visitors at Seven Oaks.
34 residents, two staff and two visitors from Seven Oaks have been
admitted to hospital.
The majority of cases are improving but some have worsened as the illness
takes its course.
Testing continues to determine the cause of the illness.
Hospitals and their emergency rooms are operating normally.
"We are working with staff at the home and the Ministry of Health and
Long-Term Care to ensure appropriate measures continue to be in place to control
the outbreak," Dr. McKeown said.
Mystery illness kills 4 more seniors
October 5, 2005
TORONTO
Four more residents of a nursing home for elderly people have died of an
unknown respiratory illness, bringing the number fatally infected to 10,
Toronto's chief medical officer said Tuesday.
Dr. David McKeown said the outbreak at the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged has
affected 84 residents, employees and two visitors to the nursing home on the
outskirts of Toronto.
Health officials have said they have ruled out influenza, avian flu, severe
acute respiratory syndrome or SARS, and Legionnaires' disease.
Mystery virus
hits Toronto: ten people dead
5 October 2005
Ten people have died from a mystery viral outbreak at a
Toronto nursing home and another 40 are in hospital, public health officials
said on Tuesday as they raced to contact anyone who visited the home recently.
The outbreak, an unidentified respiratory virus, has sparked memories of the
SARS outbreak two years ago that killed 44 people in
Canada's largest city.
But health officials said the latest outbreak, which was first detected on
September 25, is under control although they warned that more deaths could be
expected.
Four new deaths were added to the toll on Tuesday, all of them elderly residents
at the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged. All of the dead were aged between 50 years
to 95 years.
"Although the condition of some ill residents has worsened and unfortunately
four more have died, others are improving and we are confident this outbreak is
under control," said David McKeown, Toronto's medical health officer.
Health officials have ruled out SARS, avian flu and influenza and are awaiting
lab results, reports the Reuters.
Six more seniors dead from mystery T.O. outbreak
Six more residents of a Toronto seniors' residence home are dead from a
mystery respiratory illness, raising the death toll to 16.
"It's obviously something new," infectious disease specialist Dr. Neil Rau
told CTV News. "It's either a new virus, or it's a play on an old virus that's
become a little more virulent to the point of causing very significant disease
in elderly people."
Toronto's medical officer of health, Dr. David McKeown, said there have been
no new reported cases in the last 24 hours.
Public health officials say the cause for the outbreak at the Seven Oaks Home
for the Aged in the city's east end remains unknown but that they are continuing
testing. However, they maintain that the situation is under control.
"I think that if in a week we can't figure this out, it's time to get some
international help," Dr. Rau said.
"What we are seeing is a pretty virulent pathogen that is causing this
outbreak," said Dr. Donald Low, medical director of the public health
laboratories branch in the Ministry of Health, appearing on CTV Newsnet.
Low has analyzed tissue samples from one of the victims who just died. Health
officials have have ruled out influenza, avian flu, SARS (severe acute
respiratory syndrome) and Legionnaires' disease.
"So our task right now is to find out...what the cause is," Low said. "And
that's what we are doing... literally working day and night with clinical
specimens to find out what is causing this."
A total of 38 people are in hospital; 34 of them are residents, two are
staff, and two are visitors to Seven Oaks.
Since the outbreak began on Sept. 25, 70 residents, 13 employees and five
visitors have become ill.
"The majority of cases are improving but some have worsened as the illness
takes its course," a statement released by the city's public health officials
said Wednesday.
"What is reassuring, despite the fact that the number of deaths are going up
is that the number of new cases per day is dropping," said Dr. Rau. "We have to
watch a little longer, but it looks like that is a favourable trend."
Ontario Health Minister George Smitherman urged caution, saying there is no
evidence to suggest the outbreak has spread beyond the seniors' home.
Smitherman noted Wednesday that respiratory illnesses afflicting vulnerable
patients such as seniors are not uncommon.
"These are not circumstances that are new," he said. "We're struggling with
circumstances like this always in the institutional environment."
Dr. Low agreed, saying such outbreaks have been around for decades.
"It is just now that we have the technology that we can actually identify
them, and hopefully actually tell you what is causing them," he said.
Anxiety over the outbreak has been aggravated by fears of SARS in Toronto, a
city still reeling from the effects of the respiratory illness.
In 2003, two SARS outbreaks in the Toronto area killed 44 and sickened
hundreds. Worldwide, more than 8,000 people contracted the illness and 774
people died.
Meanwhile, the Greater Toronto Hotel Association has released a confidential
memo to hotels in the city, urging them to be on alert that visitors and foreign
media may pick up on the story and draw unwarranted comparisons to the SARS
outbreak.
Among a list of bulleted recommendations, officials are warned that speaking
out on the issue may make them appear "defensive."
"The only threat here is if people get carried away with hysteria (or if the
outbreak escalates significantly, but there appears no reason to suspect it
will)," the memo says.'
"We can inform anyone who asks that we are monitoring the situation closely.
Of course we can't appear to be dismissing it out of hand.
"But the biggest threat to tourism is not a respiratory outbreak, it's a
hysteria outbreak. That's what we need to contain. We certainly do not want to
make any comments that refer to SARS or "last time."
Hotel officials are urged to limit any comment to the theme: "Toronto is one
of the safest cities in the world, and that's as true today as ever."
The memo follows in the footsteps of increasingly intense media coverage on
the outbreak.
The city's tourism and hospitality industry was hard hit by the SARS crisis
after the World Health Organization put Toronto on a list of areas fighting SARS
in 2003, thus driving away potential tourists leery of becoming infected
Mystery Illness Kills 16 People In Toronto
October 5, 2005
TORONTO
A deadly outbreak of a respiratory illness at a Toronto nursing home for
the elderly has claimed six more lives, raising the death toll to 16, health
officials said Wednesday.
The cause of the outbreak at the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged remains
unknown, although officials insisted the situation was under control.
Thirty-eight people remained hospitalized with the illness, and officials fear
many of them are too frail to fully recover. Another 88 residents, employees
and visitors have been affected.
Public health officials have said it may never be possible to determine the
exact type of bug responsible for the rash of illnesses, but they have ruled
out influenza, avian flu, SARS and Legionnaires' disease.
Health minister urges Ontarians to get
flu shot after seniors' home outbreakat 15:05 on October 5, 2005, EST.
5 October 2005
TORONTO
A deadly outbreak of a respiratory illness at a Toronto seniors' home is a grim
but timely reminder that Ontario residents should get their free flu shot this
year, Health Minister George Smitherman said Wednesday.
The mysterious illness at the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged has killed 10
people and affected more than 80 others, but Smitherman said he's confident the
outbreak is contained and under control. Even though the cause of the outbreak
is unknown, Smitherman said it highlights the need for people to take necessary
precautions to stay healthy.
"It really does help to remind people that as relates to the flu, it's
serious, and accordingly we really need to encourage people to take advantage of
those free flu vaccines," he said, noting that not all provinces offer free flu
shots to residents as Ontario does.
People should also remember that a simple act like proper handwashing can
also prevent the spread of illnesses, Smitherman said.
The minister said there's no evidence to suggest the outbreak has spread
beyond the Seven Oaks home, but he noted that respiratory illnesses are common
among vulnerable groups of people like seniors.
"These are not circumstances that are new," he said. "We're struggling with
circumstances like this always in the institutional environment."
"But I do feel that lessons have been learned from SARS have been
well-applied here."
The outbreak is being carefully monitored by public health officials,
Smitherman said.
"Of course we're monitoring it vigorously," he said. "I'm very confident that
the steps that have been taken are the appropriate ones."
Date: Fri, 7 Oct 2005 09:27:16 -0400
From: Susan Squires <susan_squires1
TA phac-aspc.gc.ca>
Source: Jeannette Macey, Susan Squires, Ottawa, Public Health Agency of
Canada, & Erika Bontovics, Toronto, Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-term
Care [edited]
Since 2 Oct 2005, no new cases of FRI (febrile respiratory illness) have been
identified in connection with a respiratory outbreak in a Toronto nursing home.
A FRI case is defined as a resident, staff member or visitor with sudden onset
of fever with malaise and/or anorexia, with or without runny nose and congestion
or cough.
In total, 93 cases, including 16 deaths, have been identified to-date. The case
breakdown is as follows: 70 residents, 16 staff and 7 visitors. All deaths
have occurred in residents of the nursing home. Cases are rapidly improving
upon initiation of antibiotic therapy.
Autopsy specimens were received from 7 patients through the coroner's office and
tested by the Central Public Health Laboratory in Toronto. All were tested for
_Legionella pneumophila_ by DFA and culture. To-date specimens from 3 deceased
patients are positive for _L. pneumophila_. Culture results on the other 4
deceased patients are pending.
A masked health care worker greets an unidentified women who came to the
front doors of Seven Oaks Home for the Aged.
As a result of this ongoing surveillance, outbreaks are regularly detected,
especially during the influenza/respiratory season, which we are now entering in
Canada. The 1st outbreak of laboratory-confirmed influenza for the 2005-2006
season was reported in a long-term care facility (LTCF) elsewhere in the country
last week, and other common respiratory viruses are circulating as well.
(see Canada's weekly FluWatch surveillance report at: <http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/fluwatch/index.html>
)
In terms of the larger picture with respect to the respiratory [illness] season
in Canada, we are likely to see many reports of respiratory outbreaks in nursing
homes and other institutions. As is often the case, a proportion of these
outbreaks may not have any identifiable etiologic agent. Using increasingly
sophisticated molecular testing techniques, laboratory scientists
are able to detect and identify previously unrecognizable pathogens, e.g. new
coronaviruses and parvoviruses etc. As a result, appropriate risk assessment is
an important accompaniment to these reports, especially given the current wide
media coverage of respiratory illnesses/outbreaks.
Susan Squires
Senior Epidemiologist
Immunization and Respiratory Infections Division (IRID)
Division d'immunisation et des infections respiratoires (DIIR)
Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC)
Agence de santa publique du Canada (ASPC)
Building #6, AL 0602D, Tunney's Pasture
Ottawa, Ontario Canada K1A 0L2
susan_squires1 TA phac-aspc.gc.ca
[ProMED-mail would like to thank Dr. Squires and the Public Health Agency of
Canada for sending this update on the outbreak in Toronto. The last paragraph
is a very accurate and astute assessment of the situation most departments of
health in the northern hemisphere are facing at this time of year and moving
forward.
With the current concerns regarding when and where the next influenza pandemic
will arise (and in the shadow of the SARS epidemic in 2002/2003), and on public
health preparedness to both identify the onset of the pandemic early as well as
to develop and implement control measures rapidly, there is a heightened focus
of the media on coverage of outbreaks of febrile respiratory illness. This
current outbreak came to the attention of the media because it was "different"
from the majority of febrile respiratory illness outbreaks in long-term care
facilities, and in fact, the etiologic agent turned out to be _Legionella
pneumophila_.
October 6, 2005 Statement by Dr. David McKeown, Medical Officer
of Health
Announcement re: Respiratory Outbreak at Seven Oaks Nursing Home
Laboratory testing on autopsy specimens from three residents of Seven Oaks Home
for the Aged were reported this afternoon as positive for Legionella
pneumophila, the bacterium that causes Legionnaires Disease. This indicates that
the cause of the current outbreak is likely Legionnaires Disease.
Legionnaires Disease is a form of pneumonia caused by bacteria formed naturally
in the environment, usually in water. The bacteria grow best in warm water such
as hot water tanks, large plumbing systems and air conditioning systems. People
get Legionnaires Disease when they breath in air contaminated by droplets of
water containing the bacteria. Legionnaires Disease is not transmitted from
person to person. Most cases can be successfully treated with antibiotics,
although older people with underlying health conditions are more likely to
become seriously ill and die.
The Legionnaires Disease at Seven Oaks is confined to the nursing home. Because
Legionnaires Disease is not transmitted from person to person, there is no risk
to the general community.
There have been no new cases of infection for the past two days and it appears
that transmission of the illness has subsided. There have been no further
deaths.
Further testing will be carried out to confirm these findings. In the meantime
Toronto Public Health is taking immediate action to protect the health of
residents and staff.
All staff and residents will be offered preventive antibiotics.
All staff and residents will be monitored and receive blood tests to
identify any additional cases.
Comprehensive environmental investigation is immediately underway to
identify the source of bacteria.
The ventilation system will be shut down for inspection and samples will
be taken for analysis.
Bottled water will be brought in for staff and residents.
Any further action will be determined by the findings of the
investigation.
The disease that has killed 16 people at a Toronto nursing home has been
identified. The current outbreak at the nursing home is likely Legionnaires'
Disease, officials said Thu [6 Oct 2005].
3 of the 16 people who died at the 7 Oaks Home for the Aged tested positive for
the pneumonia-type illness, Dr. David McKeown, Toronto's medical health officer,
told a press conference on Thursday.
Dr. McKeown said there have been no new deaths since Wednesday and it appears
that the cases have been waning.
The bacteria that cause the illness are found in water, the health officials
said. Legionellosis is not an airborne disease, they said.
Toronto Mayor David Miller emphasized that the city's general population has
never been at risk because of the outbreak.
"In identifying the source we are now able to move effectively to address
it."All 16 people who died of the respiratory illness that surfaced on 25 Sep
[2005] were elderly, and frail from other medical problems. The latest victims
were 3 men, who were 75, 84 and 89, and 3 women, who were 85, 92 and 96. In all,
70 residents were affected, along with 13 staff members and 5 visitors.
The name "Legionnaires' disease" came from an illness that swept through a
convention in 1976 in Philadelphia. That convention was held by the American
Legion of Pennsylvania. Eventually, the bacterium responsible for the disease
was isolated and [called] "_Legionella pneumophila_."
Since the until-now mystery illness appeared, officials have taken pains to
emphasize that it is in no way comparable to the severe acute respiratory
syndrome [SARS] in 2003 that killed 44 people in the city.
On Thursday, Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty issued a word of caution against
those tempted to compare the death of the residents with the outbreak of SARS.
Mr. McGuinty insisted that medical experts have concluded that the [bacterium]
was contained and that it posed no threat of spreading.
The Premier insisted that there was nothing unusual about the recent outbreak
which was not "dissimilar to what happens from time to time" in long term care
homes.
October 7, 2005 Legionnaires' disease investigation continues
Toronto Public Health continues to investigate the Legionnaires' disease
outbreak at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged, Dr. David McKeown, Medical Officer of
Health, said today.
Results of the environmental investigation are not expected until late next
week. Investigators are examining possible sources and samples are being sent to
the Ontario Public Health Laboratory.
There have been no new cases of the disease since Tuesday. There has been one
additional death, for a total of 17.
A total of 70 residents, 18 staff and nine visitors have been affected by the
disease. There are 35 residents, two staff and five visitors being treated in
hospital.
Most of those affected are improving and some have been discharged from
hospital.
The home remains closed to new admissions and most visitors. The home's
ventilation system remains shut down.
Bottled water is being brought in for both the home and the adjacent Seven Oaks
Child Care Centre while the onsite water system is shut down for investigation.
Toronto's drinking water remains safe for residents.
PRESS
RELEASE
THE RESPIRATORY ILLNESS IN TORONTO
HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED: IT CAN BE CURED
Situation
in Toronto now under control
The
Canadian Embassy in Italy notifies that on October 6, 2005, the Health
Authorities of the Province of Ontario have identified the respiratory disease
as legionaires disease that struck several guests of the Seven Oaks seniors
residence in Toronto.
Moreover, we
hereby communicate that:
•Legionaires disease is a form of pneumonia of bacterial form, not viral,
that can be cured by taking antibiotics.
•Preliminary research results exclude any connection of the illness to
SARS or Bird flu.
•Legionaires disease is not transmitted from human-to-human but comes from
direct contact with aircondition systems containing contaminated water.
•In the past two days there have been no new cases.
Casualties were limited exclusively to the senior’s residence and there
is no risk of contagion among the population. Therefore, please note that there
is no danger to travel to Canada. According to the World Health
Organisation, other countries have no reason to be concerned.
La legionela causa el brote mortal de Toronto
8th October 2005
La bacteria de la legionela fue la causante de la muerte de 16 personas
mayores durante las últimas dos semanas en una residencia en Toronto (Canadá),
según confirmaron ayer las autoridades médicas de esa ciudad. "Las pruebas de
laboratorio realizadas en las autopsias de tres residentes resultaron positivas
con la bacteria Legionella pneumophila", afirmó ayer el jefe médico de
Toronto, David McKeown.
Las autoridades habían afirmado en los últimos días desconocer la causa de la
enfermedad respiratoria, aunque habían descartado el Síndrome Respiratorio Agudo
y Grave (SRAG) y la gripe aviar.
Hasta la noche de ayer, seguían hospitalizadas 38 de las 88 personas
afectadas, entre las que se encuentran residentes, trabajadores y visitantes de
la residencia.
El brote de legionela en Toronto es vigilado por la Organización Mundial de
la Salud (OMS), a pesar de que las autoridades de la provincia han seńalado que
este tipo de infecciones "son normales en residencias de ancianos y ya está
controlado".
Canadá:
La legionella es la posible causa de la muerte de 16 ancianos en
Toronto
7 October 2005
Las autoridades médicas de Toronto han seńalado este viernes que creen que la
legionella es la causante de la muerte de 16 personas que vivían en una
residencia de ancianos de la ciudad.
"Las pruebas de laboratorio realizadas en las autopsias de tres residentes de
la residencia Seven Oaks han resultado positivas con la bacteria que
causa la enfermedad del 'legionario'", ha afirmado David McKeown, jefe
médico de Toronto.
El sanitario ha ańadido que "esto indica que la causa del actual brote
en la residencia de ancianos es probablemente la enfermedad de la legionella".
Desde el pasado 25 de septiembre, más de 70 residentes de Seven
Oaks, 13 trabajadores de la institución y varios visitantes han
contraído una infección respiratoria que ha causado la muerte,
hasta el momento, de 16 personas.
Esta información contradice a los responsables médicos de la ciudad
y de la provincia de Ontario que habían concluido que la enfermedad no
estaba causada por la gripe aviar, el virus de la gripe o la
legionella.
La légionellose ŕ l'origine de 16 décčs ŕ Toronto
Vendredi 7
octobre 2005
L
es
autorités médicales de Toronto ont annoncé jeudi en fin de journée que la
mystérieuse infection respiratoire ayant coűté la vie ŕ 16 personnes âgées d'un
foyer de Toronto était en fait la maladie du légionnaire ou légionellose.
"Les analyses de laboratoire effectuées ŕ partir des autopsies de trois
résidents de la maison "Seven Oaks Home for the Aged" sont positives en ce qui
concerne la "legionella pneumophila", la bactérie qui cause la maladie du
légionnaire", a déclaré le chef du service de santé de Toronto, le Dr David
McKeown.
"Parce que la maladie du légionnaire ne se transmet pas de personne en personne,
la population ne court aucun risque", a-t-il rassuré en précisant "qu'aucun
nouveau cas d'infection au cours des trois derniers jours" n'a été répertorié et
"qu'il n'y a eu aucun nouveau décčs" depuis mercredi.
Trente-huit personnes étaient toujours hospitalisées jeudi, selon les
responsables des services de la santé publique de Toronto.
Au total, 70 résidents, 13 employés et cinq visiteurs du "Seven Oaks Home for
the Aged" ont été contaminés depuis la découverte du virus le 25 septembre.
"Ces résultats sont préliminaires. Nous allons continuons d'effectuer des
recherches dans d'autres directions, mais nous pensons bien avoir affaire avec
la maladie du légionnaire", a indiqué Donald Low, membre du laboratoire de santé
publique de l'Ontario.
La "maladie du légionnaire" est une infection respiratoire provoquée par une
bactérie hydrophile, qui se développe dans les systčmes de climatisation ou les
douches mal désinfectées et touche particuličrement les personnes âgées. Ses
symptômes ressemblent ŕ ceux de la grippe: nausées, fičvre et perte d'appétit.
Le foyer "Seven Oaks", qui héberge habituellement 249 personnes, ne sera pas
fermé, le systčme de climatisation a été débranché, de l'eau en bouteille de
męme que des antibiotiques préventifs ont été distribués aux résidents et au
personnel de l'établissement, a précisé M. Low en ajoutant que la source de la
bactérie n'est pas encore connue.
"Il n'y a pas et il n'y a jamais eu de menace pour le grand public ŕ Toronto", a
affirmé le maire de la ville, David Miller.
"Nous avons bénéficié des leçons tirées du passé", a-t-il poursuivi dans une
référence ŕ la crise du SRAS (syndrome respiratoire aigu sévčre), qui avait fait
44 morts en 2003 dans le centre financier du Canada.
Vendredi, les autorités avaient fait part des quatre premiers décčs dus au
mystérieux virus respiratoire. Le nombre est ensuite passé ŕ six dimanche, dix
mardi et 16 mercredi.
Cette épidémie rappelait de pénibles souvenirs aux cinq millions d'habitants de
la métropole économique du Canada, oů la pneumonie atypique avait tué 44
personnes en 2003 et provoqué un grave ralentissement économique.
"Il ne s'agit pas du SRAS", avait cependant déclaré mercredi ŕ la presse un haut
responsable de la santé, le Dr David McKeown.
"L'épidémie étant confinée aux résidents, aux employés et aux personnes
associées de prčs ŕ cette institution, il n'y a donc pas de risque pour la santé
publique", a-t-il insisté.
Les six personnes dont la mort a été annoncée mercredi luttaient déjŕ depuis
quelques jours contre la bactérie et avaient également d'autres problčmes de
santé, a précisé le Dr McKeown dans un communiqué. Ces personnes, trois hommes
et trois femmes, étaient âgées entre 75 et 96 ans.
Les autorités avaient noté mercredi qu'aucun nouveau cas d'infection n'avait été
signalé dans les 24 derničres heures.
Jeudi, trente-quatre personnes âgées, deux employés et deux visiteurs étaient
toujours traités en isolement dans des hôpitaux de Toronto.
L'état de santé de la majorité de ces personnes s'améliore, mais se dégrade pour
certains, avaient indiqué mercredi le Dr McKeown sans précision.
"Nous sommes maintenant confiants de pouvoir contrôler l'épidémie", avait-il
déclaré, en soulignant que le nombre de nouveaux cas signalés n'avait cessé de
diminuer depuis le 29 septembre, signe, selon lui, que la maladie régresse.
Decedute 16 persone in una casa di riposo a Toronto,
38 in ospedale Canada: il virus «misterioso»
č la legionella
In realtŕ č un batterio responsabile del morbo del
legionario, č conosciuto ed č trattabile con antibiotici
TORONTO - Le autoritŕ sanitarie canadesi tirano un sospiro di
sollievo: il virus misterioso che ha ucciso sedici persone in una casa
di riposo (e altre 38 restano ricoverate in ospedale) č quasi certamente
la legionella: quindi non un virus ma un batterio. Perciň qualcosa di
conosciuto, anche se molto pericoloso in quanto provoca il mortale «morbo
del legionario». Lo ha comunicato il dottor David McKeown, responsabile
sanitario di Toronto. Due analisi su tessuti prelevati da persone
decedute hanno dato questo risultato e una terza l'ha confermato.
Analisi precedenti, effettuate sulle urine di persone che avevano
contratto il morbo, non avevano, perň, dato risultati positivi.
Ulteriori accertamenti sono in corso.
Č UN
BATTERIO - Fra i sintomi del morbo del legionario vi sono febbre,
brividi, stanchezza, mal di testa, dolori muscolari e perdita d'appetito.
A Toronto si verificano in media quattro-dieci casi all'anno di morbo
del legionario. Si tratta di una malattia di natura batterica e, dunque,
trattabile con gli antibiotici. La malattia non si trasmette da persona
a persona e quindi le minacce di epidemia sono rientrate. Nel corso di
una conferenza stampa delle autoritŕ sanitarie di Toronto č stato
comunicato che nelle ultime 24 ore non si sono registrati nuovi decessi
né si sono manifestati nuovi casi, anche se molti anziani ricoverati
sono in gravi condizioni. Non č chiaro come il morbo abbia attaccato la
casa di riposo ma, come hanno ricordato i sanitari, il batterio vive
molto bene nell'acqua. Spesso sono stati contaminati gli impianti di
aria condizionata.
07 ottobre 2005
Friday
2005-10-07, Nepszabadsag (Hungarian)
A "legionárius betegség" okozta a
rejtélyes járványt Kanadában
Több napi vizsgálatok után a kanadai egészségügyi hatóságok kiderítették, hogy
legionárius megbetegedés végzett egy torontói nyugdíjasotthon 16 lakójával -
közölték csütörtökön a kanadai nagyváros illetékesei.
A kór a múlt hét végén ütötte fel a fejét, és a szakemberek
laboratóriumi vizsgálatok sorozatával sem tudták kideríteni azt, hogy milyen
vírus okozza a Seven Oaks Home for the Aged nevű intézetben a lakók, az
ápolók és a látogatók megbetegedését, illetve az élemedett korúak halálát.
Kizártnak tartották azonban, hogy madárinfluenza vagy atípusos tüdőgyulladás
lenne a járvány oka, sőt idesorolták a legionárius megbetegedést is.
Az egyik legutóbbi teszt azonban kimutatta a legionella
pneumophila vírust. Így bizonyossá vált, hogy mégiscsak a legionárius
megbetegedés okozta a járványt, amely egyébként csak a nyugdíjasotthonra
korlátozódott.
Ezt a betegséget, tudományos nevén: legionellózist egy
philadelphiai szállodában 1976-ban amerikai legionáriusok által rendezett
nagygyűlés kapcsán ismerték fel. A 4400 résztvevő közül 182-en tüdőgyulladás
tüneteivel megbetegedtek, és 29-en meg is haltak. Mint később
megállapították: a gyilkos vírus a légkondicionáló páradúsítójából került a
levegőbe.
A fertőzés emberről emberre nem terjed, így már nem kell
tartani attól, hogy a napokig rejtélyesnek bizonyult kór egy tömeges méretű
járvány kitörésének veszélyét jelentheti.
Dřr av mystisk sykdom i
Canada
En mystisk sykdom i Canadas střrste by Toronto har tatt fire
nye liv.
Onsdag 05.10.2005,
Totalt er 10 mennesker dřde av den mystiske sykdommen.
Mens man fortsatt leter etter ĺrsaken til
dřdsfallene, sier helsemyndighetene at det kan bli svćrt vanskelig ĺ finne
ut av den eksakte typen virus elle bakterie som er ansvarlig for sykdommen.
De har imidlertid utelukket influensa, fugleinfluensa, SARS og legionella.
Flere obduksjoner har blitt gjort, men de har ikke gitt svar.
Sykdomsutbruddet startet forrige uke pĺ et pleiehjem, og 84
mennesker har hittil blitt smittet.
Flesteparten av de smittede er beboere, men ogsĺ flere pleiere og to
besřkende er blitt syke. 40 mennesker er blitt innlagt pĺ sykehus, ifřlge
Torontos helsesjef, Dr. David McKeown.
Toronto, 08 ottobre 2005 - 09:00
CANADA: MORBO LEGIONARIO, SALE A 17 BILANCIO DEI MORTI
E'
salito a 17 il bilancio delle morti alla casadi cura per anziani Seven
Oaks di Toronto. Gli inquirenti continuano a indagare sui decessi, la
cui causa, apparsa misteriosa per giorni, e' stata identificata nel
morbo del legionario, una malattia causata dalla Legionella, un gruppo
di oltre 40 batteri che, a causa della sua forte resistenza agli
antibiotici, puo' dare luogo a forme di polmonite molto gravi e
addirittura letali. La malattia prende il nome dal raduno a Fidadelfia
dell'American Legion nel 1976, quando si manifesto' per la prima volta,
e si trasmette facilmente attraverso il sistema di aerazione. Alla
Seven Oacks non sono stati registrati altri casi tra i 70 pazienti, i
12 membri del personale e le altre due persone che hanno visitato il
centro, anche se 42 persone rimangono sotto osservazione medica.
A deadly outbreak of legionnaires' disease has claimed its 17th victim at an
east-end nursing home, but health officials insist the outbreak is contained and
that it is very unlikely new cases will arise.
Yesterday, David McKeown, Toronto's Medical Officer of Health, confirmed that
an 89-year-old woman who had been a resident at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged in
Scarborough has succumbed to legionnaires' disease.
The illness is a rare form of pneumonia that can only be contracted by
inhaling water droplets contaminated by legionella bacteria and can't be spread
from person to person.
The death toll from the outbreak stands at 17, with 70 residents, 18 staff
members, and nine visitors having been affected
A deadly outbreak of legionnaires' disease has claimed its 17th victim at an
east-end nursing home, but health officials insist the outbreak is contained and
that it is very unlikely new cases will arise.
Yesterday, David McKeown, Toronto's Medical Officer of Health, confirmed that
an 89-year-old woman who had been a resident at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged in
Scarborough has succumbed to legionnaires' disease.
The illness is a rare form of pneumonia that can only be contracted by
inhaling water droplets contaminated by legionella bacteria and can't be spread
from person to person.
The death toll from the outbreak stands at 17, with 70 residents, 18 staff
members, and nine visitors having been affected
Health officials repeated yesterday that the outbreak is nearing an end, with
no new cases identified since Tuesday.
"There are no new cases, and that suggests this is a one-time event that is
now finished," said Allison McGeer, an infectious disease consultant at Mount
Sinai Hospital.
Dr. McGeer said that Toronto usually sees between three and 10 cases of
legionnaires' disease each year.
Officials added that investigators will work through the weekend to locate
the source of the bacteria that caused the outbreak. Water and environmental
samples were taken from the Seven Oaks facility yesterday for testing.
Results of that investigation, which began on Thursday, are not expected
until late next week.
"We're very carefully monitoring it and looking for sources all around the
building," said Barbara Yaffe, Director of Communicable Disease Control. "But
it's very unlikely that [the disease] will pop up sporadically somewhere else to
this extent."
In total, 35 residents, two staff members, and five visitors are recovering
in hospital. Numerous other residents with less-severe symptoms are recovering
at the nursing home.
Most of them have been treated with antibiotics, health officials said.
Dr. McGeer played down any concern that the disease might somehow spread from
affected patients to hospital workers and other members of the public.
"[It] is not an issue for anybody else living in Toronto or any other
health-care institutions, and it's not a communicable disease," she said.
"So we don't have to worry about transmission to staff or to other residents
or within the community."
On Thursday, 10 days after the first patient began suffering symptoms,
autopsy results revealed that three of the deaths at the home were likely the
result of legionnaires' disease, which originates from bacteria that colonizes
in warm, stagnant water.
The disease spreads when droplets of water bearing the bacteria are
transmitted by wind or an air current, then inhaled. Symptoms include coughing
and fever, and the illness does the most harm to elderly people, especially
those with pre-existing respiratory conditions.
"This looks like what we call a point-source outbreak, a single event that
aerosolized large concentrations.
"And the reason you see a distribution of cases is because the incubation
period is variable from person to person," Dr. McGeer said.
"It could have come from something distant to the facility, it could have
happened within the facility -- there's a fairly large number of possibilities
where the bacteria might have come from."
One possibility being investigated is that the bacteria somehow made its way
into the ventilation system of the Seven Oaks home.
As a precaution, the home's ventilation and water system have been shut down
while inspectors try to find the source of the bacteria.
Bottled water is being brought in for both the home and the adjacent Seven
Oaks Child Care Centre and the home remains closed to new admissions and most
visitors, Dr. McKeown said.
"I want to emphasize this is purely a local precaution and that Toronto's
drinking water remains entirely safe for residents in the city," he said.
Legionnaires' investigation continues
October 11, 2005
Dr. David McKeown, Medical
Officer of Health, said today that Toronto Public Health continues to
investigate the Legionnaires' disease outbreak at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged.
Dr. McKeown provided the following update:
The Home's water supply has been flushed and is safe to use. It was
returned to service on Monday evening.
The Home's air exhaust system has been inspected and returned to service.
The Home's air intake system is still being examined and remains shut
down.
Environmental investigation of both the interior and exterior of the Home
continues and test results are expected at the end of this week.
There have been no new deaths since Friday, October 7.
There have been no new cases with onset of illness after Wednesday,
October 5.
A total of 71 residents, 23 staff and 14 visitors have been affected by
the disease.
Most of those affected continue to improve.
The Home remains closed to new admissions and most visitors.
Media Advisory - Legionnaires'
Disease update
13 October 2005
Dr. David McKeown, Toronto's
Medical Officer of Health, reported late yesterday that testing by the Ontario
Public Health Laboratory has identified two additional cases of Legionnaires'
Disease in the vicinity of Seven Oaks Home for the Aged.
The two cases
occurred during the height of the outbreak two weeks ago and both appear to have
been exposed to the disease outside the Home. The individuals live or work in
the immediate vicinity of Seven Oaks. The investigation
for a possible source of the illness continues. There is no evidence of any
continuing risk of exposure to Legionnaires' Disease.
There have been no new cases with onset of illness since October 5 and no deaths
since October 7.
Two new cases of legionnaires' disease in Toronto
14 October 2005
Health officials are investigating two new cases of legionnaires' disease
they believe are linked to the deadly outbreak that killed 17 people at a
Toronto nursing home.
Late Wednesday, Toronto's Department of Public Health confirmed that they
have identified two people with legionnaire's disease.
According to Toronto's medical officer of health, the two sick individuals
never visited the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged, but fell ill at the peak of the
deadly outbreak that was centred there.
"They have never been inside the (Seven Oaks) home," Dr. David McKeown told
CTV News. "Because of the timing we think they have the same source -- our
investigation is focused on trying to locate that source."
Even though the new cases suggest the disease was not confined to the east
end nursing home, McKeown was emphatic there is no cause for alarm.
"I think we're dealing with the same source and the same outbreak. So I'm not
concerned that we're dealing with an ongoing risk."
Nevertheless, the city's top doctor says officials have to take every case
related to the deadly outbreak very seriously.
"This has been a very challenging outbreak with 17 deaths, we take the
situation very seriously. Our investigation is continuing to try to get to the
root."
The outbreak at Seven Oaks began in late September and sickened 71 residents,
23 employees and 14 visitors to the nursing home.
There have been no new deaths since Friday, but the home remains closed to
new admissions and most visitors.
Why did test
fail to detect disease?
Ontario's
health lab was warned five years ago that the test they were using for detecting
legionnaires' was flawed, says an American expert on the disease.
"We stumbled
onto the fact that it wasn't very good, and we told them," Dr. Victor Yu told
the Star last night. Yu, of the University of Pittsburgh, was a visiting
professor at an Ontario medical school at the time.
The urine test
used in Canada did not detect the disease in patients from a Scarborough nursing
home two weeks ago. Seventeen died from the outbreak.
"The test failed us," admitted Dr. Donald Low, medical director of the
Ontario Public Health Laboratories, in an interview yesterday.
"We've got to find out why did it fail."
Reached last night, Low could not confirm Yu's assertion because he only
started with the lab in July.
The urine test was developed in Canada and had worked successfully up until the
second week of September, Low said.
"We'll find out what went wrong, but we don't think it was anything done
procedurally," he said. "It could be this is a strange subgroup of legionella
bacteria and this test might not be detecting it."
Toronto officials began testing 40 urine samples for legionnaires' on
Saturday, Oct. 1, the day after the outbreak began at the Seven Oaks Home for
the Aged, but every one came back negative, Low said.
"That was worrisome. Legionnaires' is a difficult diagnosis to make."
Then lung, kidney and heart tissue from autopsies on five of the 17 who died
were sent for testing and positive results for legionnaires' came back days
later, said Ontario's Deputy Chief Coroner Dr. Jim Cairns. Once those came back
positive, they started to look at why they were positive and the other tests
were negative, he said.
"When we took the specimens — and those (in the lung) are the best specimens
— it was not thought at the time we were taking them to find legionnaires'
disease," he said.
Low said he is confident that no patients suffered or died because of the
time lag, because they were all put on antibiotics used to treat legionnaires',
and other things.
"It didn't interfere with the management of the patients, but it (not
knowing) did interfere," he said. "If we had had an answer on Saturday, it would
have put the public's mind at rest as well as the international press."
After the positive results for legionnaires' came back, Low began trying to
get a newer, more sensitive Binax test, which is not approved yet in Canada.
Twenty-two kits were shipped here from Calgary Laboratory Services last
Saturday but because of the Thanksgiving holiday, there was a shipping delay and
they arrived Tuesday, he said.
They revealed that two more patients had legionnaires', neither of whom had
ever been in Seven Oaks, but lived or worked within a few minutes' walking
distance of it.
Low also contacted a number of his colleagues in the U.S. for help in
locating more of the Binax tests.
The Binax company specializes in rapid test kits that identify respiratory
infections; in the late 1990s, its NOW Legionella Urinary Antigen Test was
cleared by the U.S. FDA.
Low has managed to get 100 more kits shipped from the Mayo Clinic and Johns
Hopkins University.
"We'll test all the people who fit the case definition in the nursing home
and beyond that," Low said.
Public health officials are collecting cultures from water and soil to try to
find the cause but it could take up to 10 days to get the results, he said. In
past outbreaks, legionella has been linked to mist machines in grocery stores,
water filters and cooling towers. In one case, the infection occurred a
kilometre from the original site.
But Low said he's confident the problem that caused the outbreak has come and
gone because no new cases have been detected in the past six days, which
"suggests a point source outbreak and a large number of people were exposed to
the pathogen. We got a burst of legionnaires' into the environment and then it
went away."
The pattern indicates "a single short-term event sometime between Sept. 18
and 24," a source said, "and whatever produced the concentration of legionella
bacteria was probably gone before the first case appeared on the 25th. The risk
to anyone was actually over before the illness started."
Public health officials aren't surprised two cases popped up later because
they were "anticipating that the problem was in some way airborne," the source
said. "While very obviously the highest concentrations were at Seven Oaks, it
would be surprising if a few people in the immediate vicinity were not
affected," the source said. "These two are the only two identified so far with
pneumonia, and people have been looking quite intensively."
Finding the two cases doesn't fundamentally change the list of potential
sources people are looking at, the source said. There is still a "small residual
risk" of more illness but they "won't know for sure until the investigation is
over," the source said.
"So far, everything suggests the problem is gone, but it isn't for sure for a
while."
The Binax test has yet to be approved in this country, said Nathalie Lalonde,
spokesperson for Health Canada. In order for approval to be fast-tracked, the
U.S. company has to submit a priority review request to Health Canada, she said,
"and that has not been done."
Yu compared the Binax and Canadian legionnaires' tests, saying "this
particular case was the Lexus versus a Camry, I think. Or a Corolla."
TORONTO -- Ontario's provincial health laboratory was warned more than five
years ago the in-house test it developed to detect legionnaires' disease wasn't
sensitive enough, the U.S. expert who issued the caution said yesterday.
True to Dr. Victor Yu's warning, the same test failed to detect legionella
pneumophila as the source of the outbreak at the Seven Oaks nursing home that
has claimed 17 lives in Toronto.
After the lab detected the bacteria in lung tissue taken during autopsies
from some of the victims of the outbreak, a commercially available test
confirmed the outbreak was indeed legionnaires' disease.
Yu, a legionnaires' expert at the University of Pittsburgh, said he warned
the lab a number of years ago its test wasn't accurate enough.
At the time, Yu was at an Ontario medical school as a visiting professor. He
diagnosed a patient as suffering from legionnaires' but was told the provincial
lab had run its test and ruled out the disease.
Ontario Government Announces Independent Review Of Legionnaires' Disease
Outbreak
Dr. David Walker To Lead Review Of Outbreak
TORONTO, 17 October 2005
An independent review of the legionnaires' disease outbreak in Toronto will be conducted by Dr. David Walker, Minister of
Health and Long-Term Care George Smitherman announced today.
"The legionnaires' disease outbreak was a tragedy that affected some of our most vulnerable citizens," Smitherman said. "I believe that Toronto Public
Health has done a good job in managing this outbreak. We now need to look closely at what worked and what improvements need to be made, and apply any
new lessons quickly."
Dr. David Walker is currently the Dean, Faculty of Health Sciences at Queen's University. Dr. Walker chaired the expert panel on SARS and Infectious
Disease Control. This experience makes him a suitable candidate to evaluate actions taken during this outbreak, assess whether or not relevant lessons
learned from SARS were applied, and identify what can be learned from this experience in order to manage and respond to future outbreaks.
"I am pleased that someone of Dr. Walker's stature has agreed to take on this very important task," said Dr. Sheela Basrur, Ontario's Chief Medical
Officer of Health. "His experience with SARS will be invaluable."
Dr. Walker's review will examine response times, processes, communication and co-ordination between the various organizations that were involved in the
management of the outbreak. These organizations include the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care, the Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional
Services, Toronto Public Health, Toronto Emergency Medical Services, Seven Oaks Home for the Aged, and area hospitals.
Dr. Walker will begin his review immediately, with the final report presented to the public and the minister before the end of the year.
Cooling tower source of Legionnaires' outbreak
21 October 2005
Dr. David McKeown, Toronto's Medical Officer of Health, announced today that the source of the Legionnaires' Disease outbreak at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged has been identified as the
air conditioning cooling tower on the roof of the Home.
Dr. David McKeown, Toronto's Medical Officer of Health, announced today that the source of the Legionnaires' Disease outbreak at Seven Oaks Home for the Aged has been identified as the
air conditioning cooling tower on the roof of the Home.
"The source was confirmed earlier today by the Ontario Public Health Laboratory based on environmental samples collected by Toronto Public Health investigators," Dr. McKeown said. "
The cooling tower has been turned off since October 6, 2005, the day we learned that Legionnaires' was the cause of the outbreak. There is no risk to the public from this source since that time."
Lab tests showed that the cooling tower contained the same legionella bacterium found in samples taken from residents. An air intake is located near the cooling tower. Droplets containing the
bacterium were spread through the Home by the air handling system. The disease then affected a vulnerable population of elderly residents as well as staff and visitors.
A total of 20 residents have died and 127 people have become ill from Legionnaires' Disease
Source of legionnaires' disease outbreak found; 3 more deaths
October 21 2005
The cooling towers of the airconditioning system of the
Seven Oaks nursing home in Scarborough was the source of the legionella
bacteria that have now killed 20 people, public health authorities said
Friday.
"We feel confident that this is the source of the outbreak,"
said Dr. Donald Low, director of Ontario's public health laboratory.
Three people have died in recent days and eight people are
still being treated for the disease. Low says they are improving.
Since September, the bacteria have infected more than a
hundred people with legionnaires' disease.
All the people who died, and most of those who became
infected, lived at the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged. The others either worked
at the seniors home or had visited the facility recently. Four lived nearby.
The fact that people outside the building were infected led
investigators to the facility's rooftop air conditioners.
Toronto's Medical Officer of Health Dr. David McKeown says
the tower has been shut down since Oct. 6 and there is no current risk to the
public.
The province has ordered an independent review of the
outbreak.
Toronto outbreak kills 3 more
21 October 2005
TORONTO
Three more people have died from an outbreak of legionnaires' disease that
investigators confirmed Friday originated in the cooling tower of a Toronto
nursing home.
Toronto health officials said droplets were distributed into the air by the
cooling system on the roof of the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged in the city's
east end and then sucked into the ventilation system's air intake. "The
bacteria causing the disease was spread through a very vulnerable population
of elderly residents with tragic results," Dr. David McKeown, Toronto's
medical officer of health, told a news conference.
"From what we know at this point, there's no evidence that the cooling
tower was not properly maintained."
The latest three people to die were all elderly residents of the home with
a median age of 90 and pre-existing health conditions, officials said.
Health officials ordered the cooling tower shut down Oct. 6 when the
disease was detected, and McKeown said there's been no risk to the public
since that time.
"This outbreak stands as one of the most significant events on record
involving legionnaires' disease and we will be very diligent in reviewing our
work and identifying important lessons learned."
A separate, independent review of the outbreak is also being conducted by
Dr. David Walker, who also chaired an expert panel on Toronto's deadly SARS
outbreak two years ago.
Walker will evaluate the city's response to the latest outbreak and
determine whether lessons learned from the 2003 SARS outbreak were applied.
So far, 20 people - all of whom were elderly with underlying health
conditions - have died as a result of the outbreak, which began late last
month. The investigation is continuing, but there's no evidence the building's
cooling tower was not properly maintained.
All told, there have been 127 cases of legionnaires' disease, including 67
residents, 30 staff and 26 visitors.
Another four people who live or work in close proximity to Seven Oaks Home
for the Aged have also contracted the disease, likely infected by droplets
that escaped the building through the cooling tower.
Lawsuit Launched in Toronto's
Legionnaires' Outbreak Oct, 25 2005
TORONTO
A lawsuit is being launched following the deadly outbreak of Legionnaires'
disease in Toronto.
The suit alleges officials were negligent in their efforts to find the
source of the outbreak at the Seven Oaks Home for the Aged where 21 people
have died.
The suit names the nursing home, the city and the province.
Toronto: la climatisation ŕ l'origine de la légionellose
21 October 2005
Une tour de conditionnement de l'air sur le toit du centre pour personnes âgées Seven Oaks, ŕ Scarborough, est ŕ l'origine de la flambée de la maladie du légionnaire,
une infection respiratoire, ŕ la fin septembre.
C'est ce qu'a affirmé le bureau de santé publique de Toronto, qui a fait part des résultats de son enquęte, vendredi, aprčs plus d'une semaine d'analyses
Les autorités ont ordonné l'arręt du systčme de climatisation du centre le
6 octobre dernier, au moment oů l'on apprenait que la maladie du légionnaire
était ŕ l'origine du décčs de plusieurs pensionnaires. Il n'y a donc plus de
risque de propagation de la maladie par cette source, a précisé le responsable
des services de santé de Toronto, le Dr David McKeown, dans un communiqué.
La bactérie a fait 20 morts ŕ la résidence Seven Oaks, selon le dernier
bilan. Plus de 120 patients, visiteurs et membres du personnels ont aussi été
contaminés.
La bactérie ŕ l'origine de la maladie du légionnaire, ou légionellose, se
développe dans les systčmes qui produisent de la vapeur d'eau. Les systčmes de
climatisation ou les douches mal désinfectées sont des endroits
particuličrement propices.